meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
My History Can Beat Up Your Politics

THE ZINGER THAT SAVED AMERICA: WEBSTER'S REPLY TO HAYNE

My History Can Beat Up Your Politics

Bruce Carlson

News, History, Politics

4.61.2K Ratings

🗓️ 10 November 2025

⏱️ 53 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

The Union threatened by legislative fiat, a Senator rose to reply to another. For Daniel Webster, it was a real comeback, What we might call a "zinger" today. "Not Liberty First and Union Afterwards! ...but Liberty and Union now and Forever One and Inseparable," Though since it was a 19th century zinger, it took 4 hours to deliver the line. Still it would become some of the most famous oratory in Senate history. When South Carolina's Senator Robert Hayne spoke in the Senate in 1830 to criticize Massachusetts and its Senator Daniel Webster, his comments were governmental but his intentions were personal. Haynes was an ally of John Calhoun, and he sought to reduce that Senator's reputation and the New England influence in federal government with a stunning interpretation of how the Constitution should work. A state could interpret any law the way it wished, he argued. . And although several friends told him not to, Haynes aimed his remarks purposefully at the Senate's best Speaker. Then Webster replied, He defended the patriotism of his home state, attacked the logical points Hayne and made about a state's right to veto a federal law, and called for the Union to be cherished. Although he and Andrew Jackson were not allies, Daniel Webster's speech set the stage for the Jackson administration's position in the upcoming South Carolina tariff nullification crisis. His speech, and the resulting consensus of agreement in Congress with his side, also set standards for federal and state roles in government, and that still has lots of relevance today. We are part of Airwave Media Podcast Network Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

You're listening to an Airwave Media podcast.

0:04.7

Robert Hayne had his eye on a lot of things.

0:07.7

When he stepped on the Senate floor, January 29, 1830.

0:24.8

He was a veteran of the War of 1812.

0:34.0

And his state, South Carolina, had sent him to the Senate with the job of protecting its interest.

0:41.2

As any senator does, then, and really now, but a little more so because the state's champion, John Calhoun, was sitting in the Senate silenced. That's because he had a

0:49.5

gavel in his hand. He had been elected vice president. And therefore just was presiding over the body,

1:03.0

which he was not welcome to speak or opine on matters before that body's consideration.

1:10.0

So it was Robert Hain to speak as what was really a minor matter.

1:15.6

Small and slender, this from Senate.gov, possessed of a refined and charming manner,

1:21.6

Robert Hayne entered the Senate when he was only 31 years old,

1:26.6

one year above the constitutional threshold

1:30.3

for Senate service. Now 38, Hayne entered the Pack Chamber to launch a reply to one of his

1:37.7

fellow senators. Appearing boyish in a suit of coarse homespun, Hayne spoke for several hours.

1:45.0

And then, following a long weekend, concluded his remarks.

1:50.0

Hain eyed Daniel Webster, the senator from Massachusetts, who had artfully defended his state's interest as well,

1:59.0

Haynes sought to challenge his renowned voice

2:03.6

in speaking for his own region. In a sense, he'd call him out.

2:07.6

To what Senate.gov says, he responded in a tone of scarcely suppressed bitterness and rage.

2:30.4

And receive the perpetual encouragement and handwritten notes from the vice president.

2:33.3

This is really a minor matter.

2:37.7

It's about whether land sales should be reviewed by the federal government. He argues, states should have the right to control their own lands within their

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Bruce Carlson, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Bruce Carlson and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.