meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Tom Woods Show

Ep. 739 Libertarians Debate Creation of Israel: Compatible with Libertarian Ideas?

The Tom Woods Show

Tom Woods

Politics, Economics, Libertarian, Government, News

4.83.3K Ratings

🗓️ 16 September 2016

⏱️ 63 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

With such libertarian luminaries as Murray Rothbard and Walter Block at odds with regard to the creation of Israel and its conformity or otherwise to libertarian principles, it seemed sensible to host a debate on the subject. The resolution: "Israel was founded on the basis of legitimate homesteading of land and reclamation of lost Jewish property from previous generations of Jews."
 
Arguing in the affirmative is Rafi Farber, and in the negative is Jeremy R. Hammond.
 

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

The Tom Woods Show, episode 739.

0:03.8

Prepare to set fire to the index card of allowable opinion.

0:08.4

Your daily dose of liberty education starts here, the Tom Woods Show.

0:14.9

Folks, one of the first things you figure out when you become a libertarian is that all the U.S. presidents your teachers told you were great

0:21.5

were terrible. Learn the true history of the U.S. presidents and their crimes against liberty

0:27.5

in our new course on the presidents. Check it out at freehistorycourse.com.

0:33.9

Hello, everybody. Tom Woods here. It is the moment you've been waiting for. It's our debate on the subject of the state of Israel from a libertarian perspective. And I will point out that when I was letting people know about this and preparing them for it and tweeting it out on Twitter, I was sternly lectured. Why don't I have a debate on the creation of Germany, or why don't I have one in the creation of England, and so on and on?

1:00.2

Well, I think, because it's kind of obvious that the creation of Israel is not that long ago, it occurred within the lifetimes of many people who are still alive today, and we were able to

1:12.1

observe its creation with our own eyes, so this makes it a little bit easier. The consequences

1:18.9

of the creation of Israel are in the headlines all the time. So it seems like an important

1:24.8

issue to discuss it also because there's a difference among libertarians on this subject.

1:29.8

And I'm the sort of person who wants to hash out differences and see what kind of conclusions we can reach.

1:35.3

Well, this wasn't quite enough of an explanation for the snowflakes who, honest to goodness, can't see the difference between, well, why don't I look at the creation of Zimbabwe?

1:45.3

I just, I don't think Zimbabwe's as much in the news as Israel is, but also, as I say, we have major libertarians

1:52.2

disagreeing. Murray Rothbard and Walter Block take different views on the subject of the creation

1:59.2

of Israel. So I want to hash this out and see if we can

2:02.0

figure out who's right and who's wrong. I will link to Walter and Murray on the show notes page,

2:09.7

tomwoods.com slash 739 if you'd like to read what they have to say. But I hope after hearing our

2:15.6

debate today, you'll want to hear more about what our

2:17.9

debaters have to say. So let me introduce them to you. And in doing so, I'll tell you a quick

2:22.3

story about just how this got started. I got an email from Walter Block maybe a month ago or so,

2:29.5

and it was to introduce me to the work of Rafi Farber, whom he had co-authored an article with. They

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Tom Woods, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Tom Woods and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.