meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Realignment

573 | Danielle Lee Tomson: The Story & Authenticity Gap - Why the Center-Left Keeps Losing the Plot

The Realignment

The Realignment

Technology, News Commentary, National Security, Marshall Kosloff, International Relations, News, Public Policy, Economics, Politics, Saager Enjeti, U.s. Politics, Policy

4.82.5K Ratings

🗓️ 16 September 2025

⏱️ 80 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Danielle Lee Tomson, author of the forthcoming Under the Influence: What's Real When America Feels Fake, joins The Realignment. Marshall and Danielle discuss the right's multi-decade project of participatory, oppositional media, and why the effort culminated in President Trump's 2024 election victory. They unfavorably contrast the center-left's post-2024 response, with its focus on top-down marketing, "ideas" disconnected from a broader story and understanding of the country, highlight the importance of storytelling when it comes to creating the "common sense" that oppositional movements require, and compare and contrast the worldviews and stories of the left, right, and center.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Marshall here. Welcome back to the realignment. Hey, everyone, welcome back to the show.

0:05.5

Today's episode is about something we talk about a lot lately on the realignment, the story

0:10.8

gap between the center, the populist left, and the populist right. My guest, Danielle Lee

0:17.8

Thompson, is a writer and strategist who's worked at the University of Washington's

0:22.0

Center for an informed public and has spent years studying conservative media from Steve

0:27.3

Bannon's world to the overall influencer ecosystem. She also has a forthcoming book with Oxford

0:33.7

University Press under the influence What's Real when America Feels Fake.

0:38.7

She also has a really great substack that I really enjoy reading and recommend you all check

0:44.1

out. In this conversation, we dig into the Wright's alternative media ecosystem and argue

0:49.7

that it didn't just go viral in 2024, coming out of nowhere on the backs of big donors.

0:56.0

Instead, the right alternative media ecosystem in Danielle's telling, it's the culmination

1:01.6

of decades of participatory oppositional culture building.

1:06.4

At the same time, liberal institutions keep trying to solve this story problem with marketing, polls, focus

1:13.4

groups, attention hacks, and new publications and think tanks.

1:18.1

We get into the ways that those approaches, while necessary, will not build the overall picture.

1:23.5

We get into her writing on authenticity, vibes versus ideology, what Obama's America built

1:30.0

and lost when it got folded into the DNC, and why philanthropy faces a lot of challenges

1:35.7

when it comes to approaching this space.

1:38.8

I really enjoy this conversation.

1:40.7

I haven't spent much time actually speaking with a person who deeply studies communications at a theoretical level. It's so we probably have the realignment's highest

1:49.0

rate of scholars and academics referenced, but lots of interesting things to check out. And

1:55.5

Danielle did a great job of signposting. So hope you all enjoy the conversation.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from The Realignment, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of The Realignment and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.