meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Dating Intentionally

261. Kids vs Childfree: Dating When You're Unsure or Mismatched w/ Keltie Maguire

Dating Intentionally

Talia Koren

Relationships, Society & Culture, Education, Self-improvement

4.7596 Ratings

🗓️ 8 May 2026

⏱️ 63 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

I'm chatting with Keltie Maguire, a life coach who specializes in helping people navigate the kids-or-child-free decision — a topic we've never covered on this show before. After spending years as a fence-sitter herself before ultimately choosing a child-free life, Keltie now helps individuals and couples gain clarity on one of the most complex decisions they'll ever make. We're discussing everything from why "you'll just know" is terrible advice to why a pros and cons list won't actually help you, how to approach this decision when you're ambivalent, and why both people in a couple need to be willing to compromise. Keltie also shares how to talk about the kids question while you're dating: when to bring it up, what to put on your profile, and what to do when your person isn't sure. At the end, we tackle a dating dilemma about a woman who's finally found a stable, kind man she feels safe with, but she's embarrassed by how he looks.


MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE

Kids or Child Free Podcast (Keltie's pod)

We Are Child Free Podcast

The Baby Decision (book)

Amanda White's Substack, Fence Sitter


THANKS TO OUR PARTNERS

Boll & Branch: Get 15% off the softest bedding at bollandbranch.com/dating

Quince: Get 10% off and 365-day returns at quince.com/talia


CONNECT WITH ME:

⁠Slide into my DMs on IG @dating.intentionally

MORE FREE ADVICE & CONTENT

Download my free dating guides (texting, reflections, FAQ)

⁠Get more dating advice from me on YouTube⁠

SUPPORT THE POD

⁠Rate on Apple


See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Welcome back to dating intentionally. I'm Talia. I'm sharing no nonsense advice for navigating

0:09.8

dating and relationships with confidence and ease, whether you've been dating for a while

0:14.0

or you're just starting out. I believe dating can be fun and I'm here to help you on the process.

0:18.7

Today you're going to hear from a guest Kelty McGuire.

0:22.5

Kelty is a life coach who helps individuals and couples navigate one of the hardest decisions

0:28.0

they'll ever face, whether to have kids or live child free.

0:32.2

After spending years as a fend sitter herself before ultimately choosing a child free life

0:37.1

for their husband of 17 years.

0:39.0

She turned her personal journey into a coaching practice and podcast dedicated to helping others get

0:43.9

clear on what they actually want. Today you're going to hear Kelty share why the advice that you'll

0:49.2

just know is actually harmful and what it means to be ambivalent about having kids versus not wanting

0:56.8

them. We get into how to approach the decision and the conversation with the partner when

1:02.2

one of you is unsure or both of you is unsure or you're just not on the same side of the conversation.

1:07.0

We also talk about the kids question in dating specifically, like when to break it up, what to put on your profile and why both people in a couple need to be willing to compromise even when it's not a perfectly equal situation. And I found that so interesting. Plus, at the end, we tackle a dating dilemma from a listener who found a stable, kind, emotionally safe

1:28.4

man, but she feels embarrassed to be seen with him in public. As always, I love to hear from you.

1:34.9

So if you have thoughts on this episode, and again, this is a big topic, you can DM me on

1:39.1

Instagram at dating.com, drop a comment on Spotify, or shoot me an email at Talia at datingintentionallypod.com.

1:46.4

And if you prefer to watch these conversations, you can hang out with us on YouTube.

1:51.1

All of my episodes are on my channel, Dating Intentionally.

1:54.4

It's linked in the show notes.

1:55.7

You'll find it.

1:56.5

And thank you for hanging out with me there.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Talia Koren, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Talia Koren and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.