Late one night, a mother could be heard screaming for help.

What happened that day?

I actually felt like I was having a conversation with the devil.

She told the police that a masked gunman had broken into her home and stole her newborn baby daughter straight from her crib.

He was going to kill me. I was just in such shock.

I didn't know.

He came to take my baby from me.

It was every parent's worst nightmare.

And then three years later, it happened again.

Another hysterical call in the middle of the night.

It was the same story.

A masked gunman broke in to this mother's home and stole her newborn daughter straight from her crib. It didn't seem possible that anything could be

more horrifying until one detail changed everything. This was the same mother, making the same claim three years later about a different baby.

Welcome back to another episode of Hot in the Case and welcome to the very last episode of

2025.

I want to take this quick moment to sincerely thank every single one of you

that ever took a chance on my little show. It seems unreal that I've been doing this for an entire year,

and I'm so grateful that I'm going into 2026 with every single one of you. But we're going to jump straight in to this case.

This is the case of the daughters of Paula Sims. And my name is Brianna and I'm hot on the case.

Paula Sims was born Paula Marie Blue on May 21st, 1959, to her parents Orville and Nileen Blue,

and she was raised in small town, Missouri.

Paula's parents seemed like normal, warm parents. Orville was a hardworking family man. Nileen was a friendly homemaker. Paula's eldest brother, Dennis, tragically contracted

...