They call it the Bunny Man, or maybe Mothman, or the Jersey Devil.

Maybe where you grew up, it was Walking Sam, or the bus to nowhere, or the Candy Lady.

We're talking urban legends.

What was the first one that scared the daylights out of you?

We always have an odd one in the crowd, so it's kind of odd.

I decidedly odd.

Isn't that strike you as a little bit odd?

No, it doesn't strike me as a little bit odd.

It's the Bob and Sherry Oddcast with stuff we wouldn't, couldn't, or shouldn't do on the regular show. Now, here's the oddcast.

Urban legends, you know, that's so interesting, it's such an interesting phenomenon because

some of them just sound insane and impossible to be true. And others are just close enough to true that you believe in your heart of hearts

that it definitely happened somewhere to somebody in some former fashion. And that's how the story

got told. And I know that people believe what they want to believe. Like, I'm not saying there's not a big foot.

Because I kind of think there's some sort of something out there.

We've got so much tangible evidence.

And I can't tell you there's no bunny man or mothman or lobster boy or Jersey Devil or Nicodemus or Caddywumpus or Candy Lady or Walkin' Sam. Because I think that

there's a grain of truth. Maybe it started off just as a way to scare the kids and keep them out of

the dark forest at night. Something happened somewhere back in time. So my question for you, Max, and Doc and Lamar is,

what was the first urban legend that you remember being completely convinced was real

and having the snot scared straight out of you?

Who wants to go first?

I'll go first.

...