Well Bill, there's a YouTube video and it's on you and the Kalam Cosmological Argument.

It's called Physicist and Philosophers reply to the Kalam Cosmological Argument featuring

Penrose, Hawking and Gooth.

It's not only a long title, but it's a long video.

And you know, Bill, despite your confidence and your experience, this must have been a

little intimidating with this kind of a lineup.

Yes, when I first heard of this video with this stellar lineup of physicists and philosophers,

I was very impressed.

I mean, it looked like William Lane Craig against the world.

But when you actually dive into this video, I think you'll find that there's really

a lot less than meets the eye.

What you discover is that although the people being interviewed are great scholars, the

people who produced this video are popularizers.

And when they misrepresent the Kalam Argument to these scholars, then the inevitable result

will be criticisms aimed at a straw man.

And that greatly diminishes the value of this video.

Less for the scientific material in the video, there's really nothing new here.

It's just a rehash of old material that James Sinclair and I have already responded to

in our published work.

So the video really fails to advance the discussion.

So in the end, the video turns out to be somewhat less impressive than it at first appears.

So due to the experts featured in this video bill and its popularity, it's up to around

...