This episode contains descriptions of violence and sexual assault.

Listener discretion is advised.

Everyone called Tiffany My Shadow.

Wherever Mama went, Tiffany was with me.

It was very hard to deal with her getting murdered.

The police had no idea who to look for.

Tiffany's was just another co-case.

Whenever I got so dishearted, I go, maybe I should give up.

But then my Indian blood comes out and I go out and I talk to nature and I talk to Tiffany and the redbirds come into the yard,

which is a good symbol that means your loved one is close by. And I said, I will not give up. I will find

who did this to you.

There are 120,000 unsolved murders in America.

Each one is a cold case.

Only 1% are ever solved.

This is one of those rare stories. This is one of those rare stories. Yeah. It's almost midnight on July 6, 1997 in Bethany, Oklahoma, and Sergeant Reed is on his way to a call in the Oklahoma City suburb.

As he's driving, he spots something odd at the sunshine car wash.

A white Dodge neon was parked in the far west stall, but no one was around it. I didn't

pay much more attention. After finishing the call, I drove by the Sunshine Car Wash again,

and that same white Dodge Neon was still in the Far West stall. The Dodge Neon is the only car left at

the car wash at this late hour,

and Sergeant Reed sends the license plate number to headquarters to find out who owns the vehicle.

It's registered to 19-year-old Tiffany Johnston.

...