Hey there, and welcome back to Take One, the podcast that brings you just one

mysterious page of Talmud each day, and on today's page, Menachot 79, we have a mystery.

The mystery of what happens to the sacrificial libations when the main animal offering on the altar

is, for whatever unfortunate sad reason, disqualified.

It may sound like an intricate technicality, but follow along, and it will reveal some profound

depths of thought, logic, and feeling.

And as we do on this show from time to time, we would like to invite the great Josh

Waxman from Yeshiva University to shed light on this matter.

Or rather, we would like to invite the AI that Professor

Waxman so magically trained to read pages of Gamara and deliver surprisingly moving and

insightful analysis. As you may remember, we've featured this wonder once before on this show.

And so, here she is again, Professor Joshua Waxman's Miracle AI, telling us

some profound and fascinating things about today's Duff.

All right, today we are diving into an ancient legal case that honestly plays out just like a classic detective story.

We've got a missing item, a super cryptic clue, and an investigator who has to sift through all the evidence to find that one single truth that connects everything.

So let me put it this way. Imagine you buy your friend a brand new, top-of-the-line smartphone.

But this isn't just the phone. It comes with this mandatory accessory pack. You know, a special case, custom headphones, the whole shebang. Now, what if you lose the phone before you can even give it to them? Do you have to buy that whole accessory pack all over again when you get the replacement. That is the exact

kind of puzzle we're digging into today, although as you're about to see, the stakes are a little

more, well, ancient. At the heart of our case is an ancient ritual called the thanks offering,

or Corban Toda. It's basically an animal sacrifice someone would bring to show their grateful, but here's the crucial detail, the part you have to remember. It's basically an animal sacrifice someone would bring to show their grateful.

But here's the crucial detail, the part you have to remember.

It's not just about the animal.

...