meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Chutzpod!

Judge Jewdy

Chutzpod!

Chutzpod!

Judaism, Religion & Spirituality

5.0531 Ratings

🗓️ 2 April 2025

⏱️ 41 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Are you Jewish enough? Too Jewish? Why are we Jews so judgy of one another? Rabbi Shira and Hanna receive a letter from a listener whose embrace of Judaism as an adult is making her less religious mother bristle.  

Read an example of Jewish judging in the Torah

Support Chutzpod!

Support Chutzpod!

Submit a question

Contact Chutzpod!

Subscribe to Chutzstack

Follow Hanna on Instagram

Follow Shira on Instagram

Follow Shira on Facebook

Follow Chutzpod on Facebook

Follow Chutzpod on Instagram

Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Political tensions, anxiety, and loneliness are on the rise,

0:04.0

but problems like these aren't new, and the solutions don't have to be either.

0:08.0

For thousands of years, societies have asked questions about how to live, thrive, and love.

0:13.0

And it was spiritual traditions that offered wisdom and tools to help people find their way.

0:17.0

Tools that science is now discovering offer real benefits. Join me, Dave Dosteno, to

0:23.0

explore how we can all use this wisdom, whatever our beliefs. Listen to How God Works from PRX,

0:29.2

wherever you listen to podcasts. Hello, and welcome to chutzpah. Real life lived better, where each week we apply Jewish tradition and a little bit of side eye to talk about something that is live in our lives. I'm Rabbi Shira Stutman. And I'm Hannah Rosen.

0:52.6

Okay, Hannah, I want to open with a question as we are want to do.

0:57.2

Would you rather your children become black hat ultra-Orthodox or convert to Christianity?

1:07.5

Oh, get out of here. That's such a crap question. Oh, my God. Why? I love this question. It's such a great

1:13.7

question to, like, you know, have a, to talk about schnops with your friends. Okay, what kind of

1:19.3

Christianity? Like, are they just going to some mild Lutheran services every once in a while

1:25.0

and learning a few hymns? are they like evangelicals or Mormon.

1:29.5

Oh, that's interesting. Okay, so let's start with like the lighthearted Lutherans.

1:35.7

Do they have a Christmas tree? Oh my God, that's what it comes down to? Yes, like am I walking into the

1:42.2

house where my progeny and potentially their progeny is? And it's all Christmassy. Like, it's all like, like little goyishy things all over the house. I've never said a word like that in my life. But that's my life now. And then there's like a tiny menorah under the tree because. No, no. The menorah is actually on top of the tree instead of the angel

2:02.6

there's like a Jewish star with a menorah but anyway I need to tell you something right now

2:06.8

Hana there's like a 75% chance that will be true for your children even if they don't convert

2:12.3

to Christianity I just want to prepare you for that eventuality. Isn't it weird?

2:18.0

Like, does it speak to the shallowness of my Judaism that it's the aesthetics I'm concerned about?

2:23.5

It's not their souls.

2:25.3

Like, it's not what is their souls and what's their relationship with their tradition

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Chutzpod!, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Chutzpod! and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.