meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
TALKING POLITICS

Hong Kong

TALKING POLITICS

Catherine Carr

News, News & Politics

4.72.5K Ratings

🗓️ 11 July 2019

⏱️ 42 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

What is happening in Hong Kong? We talk to a professor of Chinese history and a Hong Kong journalist about the recent wave of protests there and try to discover what is really at stake on all sides.  Who are the protestors? What are their core demands? Can these be met? And what will happen if they aren't? Plus we explore the parallels with other protest movements around the world and look at the possible knock-on effects, from Beijing to Taiwan. With Hans van de Ven and Angus Hui.


Talking Points:


The protests in Hong Kong are now in their second month. As many as half a million people have taken to the streets.

  • There is also a smaller group of much younger people who occupied the legislative council chambers last week.
  • The initial protests were about repealing an extradition law. But the protest now seems to be about the entire system.
  • This is the 30th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre. 


The protesters want to show that Hong Kong is not China.

  • Is this a threat to one country, two systems? 
  • The Umbrella Movement in 2014 was about suffrage and democracy. Is this going beyond that?
  • One country, two systems was meant to last 50 years. We are now 22 years in. 


What would the protesters count as success?

  • Independence is an unrealistic goal. 
  • The protesters want three things: 1) The withdrawal of the extradition bill 2) An independent investigation committee into police violence against the protesters and 3) protection from prosecution for the protesters.
  • A real win would be a genuinely elected chief executive and a genuinely elected legislative council. This would involve negotiations with Beijing.


Even if these protests fade, the issues remain and will only get more serious.

  • What is happening in Hong Kong is the building up of a tradition of protests that will feed on each other.
  • There is a broader breakdown in trust between mainland China and the people living in Hong Kong, including the fear that the social credit system may be introduced in Hong Kong.


Mentioned in this Episode:


Further Learning:


And as ever, recommended reading curated by our friends at the LRB can be found here: lrb.co.uk/talking

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello, my name is David Ronserman and this is Talking Politics. Today we're going to talk about something slightly different, Hong Kong.

0:10.0

The protest there are now well into their second month and we're going to try and make sense of who the protesters are and what's at stake for both sides, not just for the people in Hong Kong but for the government in Beijing as well.

0:21.0

Talking Politics is brought to you in partnership with the London Review of Books. As politics speeds up, slow down with the subscription to the LRB where Brexit and Trump are only part of a picture that includes, well, everything else.

0:41.0

Read relevant pieces and subscribe at a special rate at lrb.co.uk forward slash talking.

0:52.0

I've got two people here with me who are going to help us understand this. Hans van der Ven is Professor of Modern Chinese History here in Cambridge and Angus Huay is a journalist with extensive experience in Hong Kong and as we're going to hear I think in a second, some personal contacts as well with some of the people who are leading these protests.

1:13.0

We're going to get to the history of this where this comes from, how it feeds into some stuff that's been going on in Hong Kong for a long time.

1:19.0

But we thought we'd start by just trying to work out who the protesters are because we've seen it. I mean, I've just been for myself here.

1:26.0

I've seen it on TV. There are kind of two presiding images for me here. One is the mass protest.

1:32.0

So these are demonstrations that have brought different numbers but hundreds of thousands of people, maybe as many as half a million or more onto the streets.

1:41.0

But we also had in the last week a much smaller group of people who are in some sense leading on this.

1:47.0

They occupied the legislative chamber. Some things happen there which we can talk about. It's a young group primarily.

1:55.0

So just tell us about them first Angus. Who are the people who occupied the chamber last week?

2:00.0

Well, I think most of them were teenagers or just youngsters. So they're mainly students. I just read some news coverage.

2:10.0

There are some disciplines that got into the legislative council chamber who is just 14 years old.

2:17.0

Yeah, yeah. I'm not quite sure he or she, but he or she just told the newspaper that she did this decision after Fairy Caval consideration.

2:28.0

So she or he was not manipulated by anybody. They decide to go there because they think there is an urgency to get into the chambers to show that this content and to escalate the protest.

2:42.0

Are these young people, teenagers and students, do they see themselves as leading on this? What's their role? What are they trying to do by escalating it?

2:54.0

I think one of the features of this protest is that most of the participants, they think that they have no leaders in this movement.

3:04.0

So everyone have their own decision and everyone respect other decisions. And that's why they just think that perhaps they do what they think is right.

3:14.0

And other protesters, we respect the decision. That's why they want to escalate the protest because the day that they got into the legislative council was on 1st of July.

3:26.0

And actually the first massive rally was on 9th of June. That the government refused to have a direct response to the public demands.

3:39.0

And without having a very good answers to protest, it decided to escalate the protest in order to have an immediately response from the government.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catherine Carr, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catherine Carr and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.