Did the Resurrection Stone come from the Vale?

Hey, brother!

Guys, let's talk about the Deathly Hallows, shall we?

They are so important to the end of the story that sometimes I forget they aren't even introduced

until the final book where they get the major spotlight.

Obviously, we've been introduced to all three before knowing their significance,

even if we never had any primary reason to assume they were important.

Dumbledore himself wields the Elder Wand. The resurrection stone first appears when Dumbledore shows Harry memories of the Gaunt family,

and Harry comes into possession of the Invisibility Cloak all the way back in year one.

But the origins of these three creations are oddly muddy in comparison to their

importance. Like even in Deathly Hallows, we're given two separate possibilities, first from

the tales of Beat of the Bard, where their gifts from death themselves and imbued with great

power, and then second at King's Cross, where Dumbledore asserts his own commentary.

So it's true? asked Terry, all of it? The Peverell brothers?

Were the three brothers of the tale? Oh yes, I think so. Whether they met death on a lonely road,

I think it more likely. The Peverell brothers were simply gifted dangerous wizards who succeeded

in creating those powerful objects.

And when it comes to Dumbledore and his guesses, we're usually inclined to assume his interpretation

of events is likely more accurate, especially when the alternative in this case is a fairy tale.

Come on. Pab-Rabity.

What?

Although I guess on that same note, Dumbledore also points out,

...