What was in the FNAF 4 box?

It's a question that's plagued the FNAF community since it first appeared back in 2015,

and yet, last year, Scott finally told us that he doesn't really know anymore.

Naturally, this felt like a gut punch to us theorists.

People were mad to say the least.

But my question is, was he wrong to do this?

Should he have planned for this better?

Or is there something else going on here that makes this decision a stroke of genius?

Hello internet!

Welcome to Game Theory, the show where the biggest challenge is thinking inside the box,

or at least, inside one box in particular, the Fnaf 4 box. This box was the big reward you got

for beating night 7 in Fnaf 4. Once you hit 6am, you'd see this box with two locks and the words,

perhaps some things are best left forgotten for now.

At the time, Scott Cawthon expected theorists to easily solve the law of this fourth game.

And once they did, he'd reveal what was inside. But after a mere month of watching the fandom

spin around in circles, he realized that no one was even close.

So instead of waiting it out, he decided to keep the box closed for good.

Writing in a steam post, perhaps some things are best left forgotten forever.

The contents of this box have been driving the fandom wild for the better part of a decade.

There have been theories upon theories wild for the better part of a decade.

There have been theories upon theories, upon theories written by every theorist from every corner of the fandom.

But Scott's remained tight-lipped, and it seemed like the box was going to join the creation

...