meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Evan & Tiki

Evan vs Tiki: The Jets “Closed” Giants Stadium Fight

Evan & Tiki

Audacy

Sports

4.2990 Ratings

🗓️ 14 January 2026

⏱️ 11 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

A casual idea for tomorrow’s Cinco turns into a full blown argument when Evan and Tiki start debating the best games ever played at old Giants Stadium. Evan plants his flag on the Jets beating the Bengals in the final game at the building, Tiki roasts him for treating a glorified preseason as history, and the whole thing spirals into condescension, yelling, and an all time “I hope Harbaugh leaves” line. Then the Cinco de Lunch-o aftermath keeps rolling: Sean gets publicly assigned the show’s “L” on YouTube for the semolina vs salmonella disaster, the chat piles on, and a caller solves Evan’s late night PB&J problem in two seconds by diagnosing the real culprit: refrigerated peanut butter.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

I think tomorrow we should all unveil our five best games at Giant Stadium.

0:06.3

You are going to be biased respectfully to the fact that that was your building.

0:10.4

You're going to be biased Sean as a giant fanboy.

0:13.1

I'll be biased as a Jet fan.

0:15.1

And then we can compare notes.

0:16.4

So I think tomorrow a very special Cinco where we all give our top five games ever at the old giant stadium. I like it, and it dawned on me. You're a pathetic human being. You know that? Wow, that was a shot across. You know? That is very harsh. I question your jet fandom. Why? Because your punchback at Tiki was a couple, you know, eh, okay, they closed the building with the Bengals. Don't you have your own 41 Donut? Yes, against the Indianapolis. Why didn't you mention that first? Because I think closing out Giant Stadium against the Cincinnati Bengals and making the playoffs after they were left to dead to me. See, you're making me spoil on my list, and I don't appreciate that. That's my number.

0:54.7

What happened after that? We won two playoff games and got to the AFC championship. What happened after 41-0 to the Colts is that they went to Oakland and lost to the Raiders. So while it's the last home playoff game they've ever had, and there's a specialness to that, which means it would be on my Cinco.

1:11.6

I do not put that ahead of them beating the Bengals on that Sunday night. I disagree. It's 41-0 versus Peyton Manning, and you haven't had a home playoff game since. It's number one for you. Here's what's going to happen now. I'm just going to give you my list now, and you guys will be the stars tomorrow with your giant... You don't have to give us the other four?

1:28.3

No, because you're getting me to debate this game. It's not number one. Well, it's personal, bit. Of course it's personal. It's debatable. I was at one of them. I was at the one that closed down Giant Stadium. It's a regular season game. Dude, it wasn't. They won and they got in. Yeah, but it doesn't mean anything.

1:44.1

Two would on my list would be the Wellington Mare game.

1:46.8

Okay.

1:47.0

That's a regular season game? Dude, it wasn't. They won and they got in. Yeah, but it doesn't mean anything. Two would on my list would be the Wellington Merrick game.

1:46.8

Okay. That's a regular season game. Oh, it's good. You have no right to tell me. The Bengals even play starters in a second half of it? It's irrelevant, bro. It's irrelevant. It's irrelevant. Now, I don't want to disrespect. Yeah, when the other team doesn't try, does it count?

1:59.4

Come on, you went to a glorified pre-season game, you put it number one?

2:01.7

That's not fair.

2:02.6

I don't want to disrespect. Yeah, when the other team doesn't try, does it count? Come on, you went to a glorified preseason game.

2:01.1

You put it number one?

2:01.7

That's not fair.

2:02.6

I don't want to disrespect my 41-0.

2:04.8

That is true. How is that number one? Because of what I... Do you want me to go through it? I mean, they didn't even try. Final game? The Bengals wanted to lose. That's fine. You want to hear my answer?

2:14.0

Okay, go ahead.

2:15.0

After the Jets lost to the Falcons a few weeks earlier on a Tony Gonzalez game-winning touchdown,

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Audacy, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Audacy and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.