Okay, on to the next question in our series of answering the questions from the Internet.

I was skeptical about this. It turned out to be a fantastic idea. People are finding it useful.

I hope you find this useful. What does from the river to the sea mean? What river, what sea, and what's wrong with saying it?

I frankly don't know who you are. I don't know if this person is pro-Israel and wants me to just explain why this is problematic from an Israeli point of view,

or if this person is someone who wants to chant it in the next protest and really tries to, wants to understand

why the heck so many Jews are so upset by it in their milieu over in New York.

I don't know who you are. Maybe that's the beauty of the internet.

From the river to the sea, the very simplest sense refers to the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea.

And the idea is the old sense of the land of Israel,

what the land of Israel is, those boundaries.

So you have a river and you have a sea.

And in between the river and the sea are two peoples,

one Jewish, one Arab.

And what happens between those two peoples,

between the river and the sea, it's been the

big question, for a century. And when people say from the river to the sea today, they generally

are saying Palestine will be free right after. The argument is it isn't enough to talk about two states. It isn't enough to talk

about a Palestinian state in the West Bank in Gaza and a division into two people's, right, two states for two nations,

and the Palestinians need to rule themselves and the Jews need to rule themselves and everybody

lives together in happiness and harmony because somebody put a border between them, right?

That's not the concept.

The concept is that is all wrong.

...