Episode 158: How Notions of 'Blight' and 'Barrenness' Were Created to Erase Indigenous Peoples

Citations Needed

Bias, News, Media, Society & Culture, Journalism, Criticism, Politics

4.8 • 4K Ratings

🗓️ 6 April 2022

⏱️ 73 minutes

🔗️ Recording | iTunes | RSS

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

"It is safe to say that almost no city needs to tolerate slums," wrote New York City official Robert Moses in 1945. "Our ancestors came across the ocean in sailing ships you wouldn't go across a lake in. When they arrived, there was nothing here," Ross Perot proclaimed in 1996. "We proved we can create a budding garden out of obstinate ground," beamed Israeli president Shimon Peres in 2011.

These quotes recurring themes within the lore of settler-colonial states: Before settlers arrived in the United States, Israel, and other colonized places throughout the world, the land was barren, wild, and blighted, the people backward, untameable, and violent; nothing of societal importance existed. It was only when the monied industrialists and developers moved in, introducing their capital and their vision, that civilization began. This, of course, is false. Indigenous people inhabited North America long before Europeans did. Poor, often Black and Latino, people populate many neighborhoods targeted for gentrification. So how do these people–inhabitants of coveted places who prove inconvenient to capital–become erased from collective memory? And what role do media like newspapers, brochures, travel dispatches, and adventure books play in their erasure?

In a previous Citations Needed episode (Ep. 155: How the American Settler-Colonial Project Shaped Popular Notions of ‘Conservation’), we discussed the erasure of indigeneity, we explored the colonialist and racist foundations of conservationism in the US and elsewhere in the West. On this episode, follow-up to that episode, we explore how images and narratives of barrenness and blight are manufactured to justify the settler-colonial project, from 15th Century colonial subjects of Europe to urban neighborhoods of today.

Our guest is scholar Stephanie Lumsden.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0	This is Citations Needed with Nemeshirazi and Adam Johnson.
0:09.0	Welcome to Citations Needed, a podcast on the media, power, PR and the history of bullshit
0:14.4	I am Nemeshirazi.
0:15.9	I'm Adam Johnson.
0:16.9	You can follow the show on Twitter at CitationsPod, Facebook, Citations Needed and become
0:21.3	a supporter of our work.
0:22.9	Through patreon.com slash Citations Needed Podcast, all your support through Patreon is so
0:28.0	incredibly appreciated as we are 100% listener-funded and run no commercials or ads of any kind.
0:34.3	As such, if you could help us on our Patreon, we'd be very grateful.
0:37.0	You'll get access to our newsletter, AMAs, live interviews, other special little goodies
0:41.3	we do for our patrons.
0:42.6	And as always, if you do like the show, please go to Apple Podcasts and rate and subscribe
0:46.9	to it there.
0:47.9	It really helps us out.
0:49.1	It is safe to say that almost no city needs to tolerate slums.
0:57.5	Wrote New York City official Robert Moses in 1945.
1:01.4	Our ancestors came across the ocean and sailing ships you wouldn't go across a lake in.
1:07.1	When they arrived, there was nothing here, proclaimed Ross Perot in 1996.
1:14.0	We proved we can create a budding garden out of obstinate ground, beamed as Rayleigh
1:19.5	President Shimon Perez in 2011.
1:22.7	These quotes capture a reoccurring theme within the lore of settler colonial states.
1:26.8	More settlers arrived in the US, Israel and other colonized places throughout the world.
	...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Previous episode | Next episode

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Citations Needed, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Citations Needed and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.