How can a good God allow suffering?

That is a question that philosophers have puzzled over and theologians have tried to answer since they have been philosophers

since there have been theologians and

Obviously, I am not gonna answer it on this episode and the reason why I'm not gonna answer it is not because I don't think there

would be good philosophical attempt to answer that question with the logical arguments for it

But on some level, right, an argument, an answer that precedes logically to this question is gonna leave you a little bit cold

because you can argue your way into understanding intellectually how a good God could allow

suffering, but when you actually are in suffering when you really hurt when you have lost

somebody you love or when you've been forced to flee your home because of political persecution or

God forbid anything even worse happens, right? In those moments, you

aren't gonna argue yourself intellectually into trusting in God or into believing that God could still be good, right?

There is something emotional about this question

This is a question that is not just about how, as it from a purely theological perspective, that is how is a

as a matter of practicality, but how can this be, right? My God, my God, why have you forsaken me that

outcry of Christ on the cross is an outcry that we all on some level, no matter how

you know, pious we are, we all end up asking that question in a deep emotional way

and so in order to answer it, you need a quite an answer that takes in the whole of life

what you really need is a work of art, you need a poem or a song or a

depiction of this that kind of grasps the

inconsolable depths of your of your spirit and says nevertheless despite the fall despite sin despite pain

God is good and ultimately his designs are perfect and so that's what we are reading today

we are reading a poem that attempts to answer that question. It's a very famous poem people have asked for it a lot on the show

...