When a confrontation between a husband and the man his wife was having an affair with erupted in violence,

two families were left to grapple with what led to that moment and how to move forward.

I'm Charlie and welcome to crime lines.

Hello and welcome to crime lines.

Before we get started, I just want to let everyone know I will be at the

True Crime Podcast Festival in Boston on the weekend of July 18th. I will be there along with my friends

from the True 1 Cold, Generation Y, True Crime Bullshit, and so many more of your favorite podcasters.

I am going to leave a link for tickets in the show notes, and I hope I will see you there.

With that, let's get into today's case. This episode takes us out to Meridian, Idaho, which is a

suburb of Boise. The case really centers around two couples. We have Emmett and Ashley Corrigan

and Rob and Candy Hall. We are going to start with Emmett and Ashley Corrigan and Rob and Candy Hall.

We are going to start with Emmett and Ashley who met while they were attending Utah State

University in Logan, Utah.

They met in the gym in 2003, and their relationship moved very quickly.

Within six months, they were married, and Ashley was soon

pregnant with their first children, twin girls. After completing their education at Utah State,

Emmett went to law school, and then in November of 2009, they moved to the Boise area,

which is where Emmett was from, and he was going to focus on studying for the Idaho

bar. This was a lot for a young family. As Emmett was in school, they actually ended up having four

children. And while he was studying, they found out Ashley was pregnant with their fifth child in six years. Because of how

much Emmett was juggling with school and then studying, Ashley really focused on the kids and the

household and figured that when Emmett finished school and he got to work as an attorney, things would

...