meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Medicine Stories

Beyond "HRT or Not?": Supporting the Bodies of Future Wise & Well Grandmothers - Jane Hardwicke Collings

Medicine Stories

Amber Magnolia Hill

Alternative Health, Society & Culture, Health & Fitness

4.71.4K Ratings

🗓️ 18 March 2026

⏱️ 66 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Perimenopause & menopause are often framed as a problem to fix- and the conversation quickly collapses into a single question: HRT or not?

But women's bodies are rarely that simple.

In this episode, Jane Hardwicke Collings and I explore a more expansive and grounded approach to the menopause transition. Rather than asking whether hormones are the right answer for everyone, we look at a deeper question: how can we support the complex physiological process the body is already moving through?

Our conversation examines the growing tendency to position hormone replacement therapy as a universal solution for perimenopause symptoms, and how that pattern echoes earlier chapters in women's healthcare, such as when the pill was prescribed for nearly every hormonal concern or when medical intervention became the default in birth.

This isn't an anti-HRT conversation. It's an invitation to widen the lens.

We talk about the many systems that influence the menopause transition and why supporting the body's foundations can be just as important as the hormonal conversation itself.

For some women, HRT may become a meaningful part of their path. For others, it may not. But reducing the entire transition to a single intervention risks overlooking the complexity and intelligence of the female body.

Just as we've begun shifting the conversation around menstruation and birth toward working with the body instead of overriding it, it's time to bring that same perspective to menopause.

LINKS:

Medicine Stories Patreon extended conversation- The Red Thread: Stories of Our Motherlines

The Womancraft Way

Quiz: Find Your Wise Woman Archetype

Healing Waters Nature Immersion Retreat in Costa Rica Nov 3-8

The Mythic Medicine herb shop

Jane on Instagram

Amber on Instagram

Medicine Stories Facebook group

Music by Mariee Siou (from her beautiful song Wild Eyes)

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

What mendopause reveals is the harvest of our lifestyle to that point. And including our red thread

0:07.8

or motherline. So our female ancestral trauma that we inherit whether we want to or not will often

0:14.3

play out in a rite of passage. It's an honour and a privilege to age. And here we are in this

0:19.7

culture that's doing everything, encouraging everybody to do everything

0:24.1

they can to avoid aging.

0:26.8

And we probably can't ride the journey of menopause without modifying our lives in the same

0:34.4

way that you can't give birth to a baby and mother it without modifying your life.

0:42.4

Hairy menopause and menopause are often framed as a problem to fix,

0:47.0

and the conversation quickly collapses into a single question, HRT or not.

0:52.1

But women's bodies are rarely that simple.

0:56.7

In this episode, Jane Hardwick,Collins and I explore a more expansive and grounded approach to the menopause transition. Rather than asking

1:02.6

whether hormones are the right answer for everyone, we look at a deeper question. How can we support

1:07.8

the complex physiological process the body is already moving through?

1:12.0

Our conversation examines the growing tendency to position H.R.T. as a universal solution for perimenopause symptoms,

1:19.5

and how that pattern echoes earlier chapters in women's health care.

1:23.4

When the pill was prescribed for nearly every hormonal concern or when medical intervention

1:27.9

became the default in birth. This is not an anti-HRT conversation. It's an invitation to widen

1:34.3

the lens. We talk about the many systems that influence the menopause transition and why supporting

1:39.7

the body's foundations can be just as important as the hormonal conversation itself. For some women,

1:46.0

hormone replacement therapy may become a meaningful part of their path. For others, it may not.

1:51.1

But reducing the entire transition to a single intervention risks overlooking the complexity

1:56.1

and intelligence of the female body. Just as we've begun shifting the conversation around

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Amber Magnolia Hill, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Amber Magnolia Hill and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.