I wanted to give Annie's family peace. I wanted to give Annie's name peace. I knew that

I could solve it, so I couldn't leave it alone.

I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anna Sige Nikolasi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation

discoveries through conviction. And this is Anatomy of Murph.

The definition of the word anatomy as in anatomy of murder is separating or dividing into parts for detailed examination.

And that examination is one of the foundations of our show. Each episode we break down a homicide, the life of a victim,

the what's of the crime and how and if it was solved. And as you know, the journey is different in each and every case.

In some investigators head in one direction only to realize it's the wrong way or an unexpected event throws everything off and a case goes cold

or a new piece of evidence changes everything. And sometimes all those things occur in the very same case.

That's what happened in today's story, which took place in Draper, Utah, a bit south of Salt Lake City.

It used to be a horse country type community and then it gradually grew until it became a community of about 40,

45,000 people when I was working there.

So while the community grew, it was also a town that still wanted to retain its history.

They do have a street with like a shopping center, but they still had codes that enforced where you could take your horse.

They still wanted to pride themselves in being small town horse-friendly.

That's Draper native Jacqueline Moore, a former detective for the City of Draper Police Department.

But Jacqueline actually began her career as a hairdresser.

I could tell that it wasn't going to be like a long-term career.

It was fun, but only part-time, so my mom had actually just gone through the academy.

So she told me how much fun it was and suggested I go on a ride along.

And the rest, as they say, is history.

...