meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Four Finger Discount (Simpsons Podcast)

A Fish Called Selma (with Josh Weinstein)

Four Finger Discount (Simpsons Podcast)

The Four Finger Discount Network.

Tv & Film, After Shows, Tv Reviews

4.8700 Ratings

🗓️ 28 November 2025

⏱️ 156 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Help us, Dr. Zaius! This week we're revisiting the classic "A Fish Called Selma" with former Simpsons writer/showrunner, Josh Weinstein.

We get first-hand insights into how the episode came together; the writing process of "Stop The Planet Of The Apes, I Want To Get Off!", Phil Hartman's live-action Troy McClure series, working with Jeff Goldblum and so much more.

Plus we discuss whether Josh regrets leaving The Simpsons, how he and Bill Oakley joined the writing staff, as well as why they made "The Principal and the Pauper". A really fun show!

Follow Josh on X at x.com/Joshstrangehill

If you enjoy this review, please consider supporting us on Patreon for as little as $1 per month at patreon.com/fourfingerdiscount

Listen on Spotify spoti.fi/4fDcSY0
Listen on Apple Podcastsapple.co/4dgpW3Z

CHECK OUT OUR OTHER PODCASTS:

Goin' Down To South Park - spreaker.com/show/goin-down-to-south-park

The Movie Guide with Maltin & Davis - themovieguidepodcast.com

The One About Friends - spreaker.com/show/the-one-about-friends-podcast

Talking Seinfeld - spreaker.com/show/talking-seinfeld

SpeaKing Of The Hill - spreaker.com/show/speaking-of-the-hill-a-king-of-the-hill-

The Office Talk - spreaker.com/show/the-office-talk-podcast

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/four-finger-discount-simpsons-podcast--5828977/support.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Dr. Zias, Dr. Zayas!

0:01.7

Can I play the piano anymore?

0:04.0

Of course you can't.

0:05.6

Well, I couldn't before.

0:11.0

This play has everything.

0:14.0

Oh, I love legitimate theater.

0:17.0

Four-finger discount, dude.

0:20.0

The Simpsom. theater. Four finger discount, dude.

0:54.5

Welcome to Forfinger Discount, dude. We're going back to review an iconic episode from season 7 of The Simpsons. It is a fish called summer. I'm Dando. And I am Guy and we are not alone. We are not alone. Indeed. We are joined this week by the showrunner at the time when this episode aired. It is Josh Weinstein, an absolute icon of the Simpsons world. He is just an absolute delight to talk to.

0:56.5

You guys are going to have an absolute ball listening to us.

1:08.8

Just talk about all the, not just this episode in general, but just all the behind the scenes of his time working on The Simpsons, post and pre-Simpsons as well. You will have a bit of fun listening to us, but mostly you'll be listening to Josh. She's got a lot to say, and he's very entertaining saying it.

1:09.1

Yeah.

1:11.7

We've got a lot of, a bit of behind the scenes dish.

1:11.7

Yeah, but a lot of say and he's very entertaining saying it. Yeah. We've got a lot of a bit of behind the scenes dish.

1:28.3

Yeah, but a lot of insight into, yeah, the creation of the show, but also, as listeners of the show, we'll know we're big, big fans of Phil Harmon and we got some great stuff about Phil because this is a very Phil centric episode. It was indeed, yeah. and he touched on how great it was to finally give Phil an episode,

1:30.4

or just give Troy McClure his own episode as well,

1:45.2

and why they wanted to do that. So we'll delve into that. But also just delve into his time at the retreats, which are really, really interesting, some really behind the scene stuff about, I know, just how they were able to get away with certain gags on The Simpsons. and a really interesting story about how he now kind of regrets leaving the Simpsons in the first place which is really interesting

1:49.4

as well so look at for that in our chat here with Josh Winson as we discussed a fish caught

1:52.9

salmon but Josh is one of those guys he and Bill they were a team when they joined the Simpsons

1:57.0

I believe season four but they were the first sort of Simpsons fans to join the writing team. And he really shines through in this interview here where he seems, you can tell he's genuinely excited to discuss his time working on the show. And as a fan, these are the kind of people, like Josh and Bill are like my two favorite people to talk to because they are fans just like you and I. And they, they enjoyed their time working on the show, and they enjoyed making their own version of The Simpsons. And it's just, it was just an absolute fantastic chat, and I'm glad that we finally got a chance to do it. No, it's great doing interviews like this, yeah, just getting a look behind the scenes at how the sausage is made. Sometimes you say you shouldn't do that, but when the sausage is this tasty, who cares how they made it?

2:51.9

Yeah, also just an insight into the karate process in general. I find them really, really illuminating. And when it's, yeah, someone is articulate and forthcoming as Josh, yeah, it's even, even better. Now, at the end of this, so basically we usually do our full run-through of the episode. So we will be doing that, but we talked with Josh. We've got about, you know, two-thirds of the way through me.

2:53.2

We've been going for an hour.

...

Transcript will be available on the free plan in 22 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from The Four Finger Discount Network., and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of The Four Finger Discount Network. and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.