meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The John Batchelor Show

5: LONDINIUM 91 AD. Carthage, Gaza, and the Risk of Unhealable Imperial Wounds. Gaius and Germanicus open by reviewing recent international news, including a major ceasefire signing hosted by Mr. Trump and proposals for US-Russia talks in Budapest, mode

The John Batchelor Show

John Batchelor

Arts, Books, News, Society & Culture

4.52.8K Ratings

🗓️ 20 October 2025

⏱️ 22 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

LONDINIUM 91 AD. Carthage, Gaza, and the Risk of Unhealable Imperial Wounds. Gaius and Germanicus open by reviewing recent international news, including a major ceasefire signing hosted by Mr. Trump and proposals for US-Russia talks in Budapest, moderated by Mr. Orbán. The conversation pivots to the analogy between the Roman destruction and subsequent revival of Carthage and the modern conflict in Gaza. Despite being destroyed in 146 BCE, Carthage became prosperous and essential to the Western Roman Empire's bread basket centuries later. Gaza, however, is a "wholly symbolic artifact of contention." Germanicus observes that Israel's dependence on the US to preserve its vision, which currently requires the emptying and incorporation of Gaza, tests the West's moral standards regarding the conduct of war. The hosts discuss whether reconciliation can occur over historical time. However, if Israel forces an expulsion of the people of Gaza—mirroring what the Romans did to Israel—the resulting transgression will be so great that the wound will become "codified in the very identity of the people who were wronged" and never heal. This unforgiven wrong risks the long-term disappearance of the US and Israel, much like how the memory of the Roman presence in North Africa was "expunged and wiped away."
1569 LONDINIUM

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Good evening. This is the Suns History Debating Society. I am Gaius. Germanicus is here. We're in Lunditium. It is a modest autumn evening. The leaves are leaving us. The river Thames is turbulent. The retired centurions are in a cheerful mood. Why not? They did their 25 years. We've been debating the map face of the empire, but we turn now to have much more fun in the 21st century.

0:40.1

Mind everybody that this is live.

0:42.3

You're not ahead of us now.

0:44.1

We're with you. And we have the news from the 21st century, such as it is.

0:48.3

For example, the signing of a ceasefire by a number of leaders in Europe,

0:54.0

the Arab world, the Islamic world, in these last days.

0:58.0

Mr. Erdogan of Turkey attended, Mr. Netanyahu of Israel did not, at Mr. Erdogan's recommendation.

1:08.0

Mr. Trump was the host, no matter the fact that it was at Charmalshikh,

1:13.2

which is a resort on the Red Sea, Egypt. That was a major event. And then the announcement

1:19.5

from the White House that the president, after a two-hour phone call with Vladimir Putin,

1:25.9

the president of the Russian Federation,

1:28.5

looked to sending their counselors, I believe, to Europe this coming week,

1:33.3

to confer in setting up a meeting at Budapest,

1:37.7

a neutral city that is loaded over by a man named Orban,

1:43.1

who's a member of NATO and a member of EU.

1:45.1

It is Hungary.

1:46.8

And it was always restless under the Soviet boot.

1:51.7

But these days, Mr. Orban is considered somewhere on the fence between Moscow and Brussels,

1:58.3

Brussels being the headquarters of NATO.

2:00.5

In any event, it was a surprise to hear that the two men were going to meet for the second time

2:04.7

since the tragedy of the Ukraine conflict.

2:09.6

Alaska was said to be unsuccessful, but now that it's led to the meeting in Budapest, if it happens,

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from John Batchelor, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of John Batchelor and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.