meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Hamilcast: A Hamilton Podcast

#479: Jeffrey Seller // Broadway Producer

The Hamilcast: A Hamilton Podcast

Gillian Pensavalle

Arts, Performing Arts

4.32K Ratings

🗓️ 4 August 2025

⏱️ ? minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Award-winning and prolific Broadway producer Jeffrey Seller has finally made it to the podcast! Jeffery has produced Rent, Avenue Q, In the Heights, Hamilton, The Cher Show, and revivals of West Side Story and Sweeney Todd, just to name a few. Altogether his shows (currently) have 22 Tony Awards, and he's the only Broadway producer to have put up two Pulitzer Prize winning musicals: Hamilton and Rent.

Jeffrey is the author of Theater Kid: A Broadway Memoir, which the New York Times describes as "a combination coming-of-age and rags-to-riches story that is unsparing in its description of his colorfully challenged-and-challenging father, unabashed in its description of his sexual awakening, and packed with behind-the-scenes detail, especially about the birth of Rent." Not to mention the audiobook is voiced by a stellar cast of Broadway voices, and talking about them gives Jeffrey an idea *in real time *during our recording. 

In our hour-long conversation, Jeffrey expands on his experience producing Rent with Jonathan Larson, including an emotional retelling of what it was like working on the show after Jonathan's tragic and unexpected death. He also discusses working with Lin-Manuel Miranda on In the Heights and Hamilton, expounds on Hamilton's social and political responsibilities (rejecting the current administration's hostile takeover of The Kennedy Center, for example), discusses ways around Broadway's current ticket prices, and candidly opens up about Andrew Lippa's The Wild Party and The Last Ship with Sting in never-before-heard specificity. 

Plus, Baz Luhrmann's La Boheme, the power of writing a letter to get what you want, and how when it  comes down to it... it's all about making shows with your friends. 

Jeffrey Seller on Instagram

JeffreySeller.com

///

Gillian's Website

The Hamilcast on Twitter

The Hamilcast on Instagram

Join the Patreon Peeps

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hi, I'm Stage in Stages, Lynn Manuel Miranda, and you're listening to The Hamelcast.

0:05.1

Boots and cuts.

0:06.5

Boots and cuts.

0:07.1

I'm going to.

0:07.4

Hi, everyone.

0:18.8

Welcome back to the Hamelcast.

0:20.1

I'm Jillian, and I know I rarely jump on the mic to do an intro like this when it's a one-off episode, but I did things a little differently this week. You're about to hear an hour-long conversation with Jeffrey Seller, prolific producer of Rent, Avenue Q, in the Heights, Hamilton, the Cher show, and the revivals of Westside Story and Sweeney Todd, just to name a few. Altogether, his shows currently have 22 Tony Awards, and he's the only Broadway producer to have put up two Pulitzer Prize winning musicals, Hamilton and Rent. Jeffrey has recently written his memoir, Theater Kid, which I highly recommend. You know how I usually start the episodes by asking people to tell me their life story? Yeah, if you want Jeffries, just read the book. It's all in there. Or listen to the audiobook, which is super fun because it's packed with familiar voices. So normally I do this little intro while Jeffrey's in front of me, but we had such a limited amount of time that I didn't want to waste a second of it, mostly because I wanted this episode to be about the listeners, specifically the Patreon peeps. In a few months, January 2026, this podcast will turn 10 years old, which I know is crazy. But so many of the Patreon Peeps have been here since the beginning, and I knew how excited they were that Jeffrey was going to record with me. And when I put out the call for questions like a week before this recording, it became very clear right away that this episode belonged to them. Their questions are always so great, and this time was no exception, so I wanted to turn it over to the peeps to get in as many other questions as possible. Full disclosure, I couldn't get to all of them, and I'm sorry about that, I really am. But hey, the good news is that pretty much anything you could possibly want to know about and from Jeffrey is in his book. All right, so now they're all on the same page, let's just get to the show.

1:45.8

Enjoy.

1:54.6

Okay, Jeffrey Seller, hi.

1:56.3

Thank you so much for being here.

1:57.9

It's an honor to speak to you, really.

1:59.7

Jillian, I'm so happy to be here with you and your peeps today. It's a beautiful Monday in June,

2:07.0

and I'm looking forward to this talk. Me too. Well, first of all, you have a new book out called

2:13.3

Theater Kid. Indeed. It is excellent. Thank you. It's really, um, fantastic to get such an insight to you

2:19.8

because you're such a giant in this community and in this industry. And so to really hear you,

2:25.2

also the audiobook is fantastic, but you really hear your voice even like jumping off the page.

2:29.4

So thank you for sharing all of this with us. Thank you for listening and reading.

2:34.0

My first call was don't bore them.

2:38.8

Look, I think that's impossible. God forbid I should bore the reader in the same way that as a producer,

2:45.8

I have to entertain the person who made the effort to buy the ticket and, um, and travel to the theater.

2:55.8

And, uh, writing a book is the same way. It's just a different experience because after you

3:00.2

write it, it's a very solitary experience between book and reader. Yeah. The same could be said for

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Gillian Pensavalle, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Gillian Pensavalle and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.