4.8 • 773 Ratings
🗓️ 13 January 2025
⏱️ 50 minutes
🧾️ Download transcript
The Russian decision to commence general mobilisation against Austria and Germany was made in the afternoon of 30 July, ultimately by the Tsar.
It took 24 hours of intense pressure by several leading Russian officials, but after backtracking the previous day, Tsar Nicholas was finally persuaded to go all in. His anxious generals were told that there was no going back - he would not change his mind again, and they could smash their telephone if they wished to guarantee it. But why were they in such a rush to mobilise the entire Russian army in the first place? Accounts of the origins of the First World War, if they cover this pivotal decision, tend to explain it as an example of Russian aggression, and proof that the Russians, rather than the Germans, were in fact responsible for the outbreak of the war. But there was more going on in the Tsar's court than this.
The Russian government had technically jumped the shark, but they had done so for several reasons which at the time, appeared justifiable. The German ambassador had warned against Russian military measures, and threatened intervention. The Austrians had begun bombarding Belgrade. Yet, by far the most consequential factor in Russia's calculations was its intelligence. This intel depicted Austria, and Germany, as preparing military forces far out of proportion to what they publicly claimed. Ironically, the Russians came to believe that their rivals were mobilising covertly, and in response, they began to do the same, with utterly catastrophic consequences for all involved...
Support the July Crisis series, join the conversation, and find out more through these links:
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Click on a timestamp to play from that location
0:00.0 | In summer 1914, the world went to war. |
0:04.6 | Now 110 years later, we go back to those figures, to those debates, to those questions, |
0:12.2 | in the greatest failure in the history of diplomacy. |
0:16.3 | I am Dr. Zach Twomley. You're listening to When Diplomacy fails. |
0:23.2 | And this is the July Crisis. After listening to Sazanov, the Tsar capitulated to the arguments of the officers. |
1:01.1 | The order for general mobilization was issued at dawn on the 31st of July. There was no other way. |
1:08.2 | Russian diplomat, Nicholas de Basili, writes in his memoirs. |
1:13.4 | By the time the sun set on the 30th of July, Germany, Austria and Russia had either |
1:19.3 | approved of general mobilization or authorized the first steps which would lead to it. |
1:25.3 | Austria would announce general mobilization the following day, |
1:28.6 | but would not implement it until the 4th of August. In the final hours of the 30th, the German |
1:33.8 | chancellor gave his approval for the state of immediate danger of war, Kriegsgfar, to begin by |
1:40.6 | noon on the 31st of July, which would lead automatically to general mobilization within |
1:46.1 | hours, unless the process was halted. There is confusion and disagreement over what these steps |
1:52.9 | meant and who made them first, but among these three actors, it is Russia that stands out the most. |
1:59.6 | Russian general mobilization was nearly implemented on the 29th of July, |
2:04.3 | and only the hesitation of the Tsar delayed it for another day. |
2:08.7 | When in the afternoon of the 30th, the Tsar was persuaded to authorize General Mobilization, |
2:14.1 | he did so because of the evidence presented to him. |
2:17.3 | What was this evidence? |
2:18.5 | And what was the mindset of those Russian officials who insisted that the country had no other choice? |
2:24.9 | Did Russia have another choice? |
... |
Please login to see the full transcript.
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Zack Twamley, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.
Generated transcripts are the property of Zack Twamley and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.
Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.