Putting a witness through that kind of interrogation on the stand, just for fishing purposes,

in other words, they have no showing a proof that she actually does have exculpatory information.

Hello, and welcome to Best Case, worst case. This is Jim Clemente, retired FBI profiler

former New York City prosecutor and writer producer of Criminal Minds. And with me today is no one

actually, I'm alone. This is me getting an opportunity because Francis outgel

she's doing something really exciting and she'll tell you about it sometime soon, but it is a

super secret mission right now. So she's having fun doing her thing and I am here to talk to

all of you. And she would say you all or y'all or something or all y'all, but no, I say all of you

because I think that's proper English and not Southern ease or whatever the hell it is that they

speak in Atlanta, Georgia. But as Francis away, I wanted to talk about a few things that are

going on. We'll start off with the Idaho case. In the Idaho case, and I don't say the name of the

offender because I don't speak the names of mess merers on any kind of media. I don't believe

that is a good thing to do. And so I'm going to continue doing that. But in my scale, Idaho,

or students were murdered, Madison, Mogen, Kaylee, Gang, Salves,

Sanana, Cernodal, and Ethan, Chapin, hope I pronounced their names right. But on November 13th of

last year, 2022, they were all brutally murdered. And that is the focus and should be the focus

of this case. Unfortunately, there's a lot of other things that are being focused on.

And well, I don't think that's actually how it should be. The fact is that recently, this week,

they published in the news that one of the surviving roommates was actually subpoenaed

to appear in a preliminary hearing. The defense wants to call her as a witness

because they say, quote, she may have exculpatory evidence. Now we all may be aware that

exculpatory evidence would be evidence that tends to disprove the guilt or prove the innocence

...