meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Catholic Answers Live

#11269 Weird Questions - Jimmy Akin

Catholic Answers Live

Catholic Answers

Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.82.2K Ratings

🗓️ 4 August 2023

⏱️ 55 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Questions Covered: 02:28 – Where does the idea of toll booths come from, and why didn’t it make its way into the Western church? 16:31 – Scotty had a little too much to drink again and staggers down to the control room at 2 am and accidentally beams up Cy. During the transport Scotty inadvertently pushes the wrong buttons and mistakenly erases Cy’s memory. Captain Kirk tells Spock to try the vulcan mind-meld hoping they can find out some information about this confused guy with the Society 315 t-shirt. During the mind-meld, Spock dies. Now Cy thinks he’s Spock. The crew decides to keep him around for entertainment purposes. Unfortunately, Cy begins worshiping Vulcan gods and then begins preaching about them and proselytizing to the crew like he’s Jimmy Swaggart. Kirk has had just about enough and drops him off on some planet in the delta quadrant where Cy lives out his days eating plants and worshiping green lava. Even though he’s now worshiping lava with full knowledge and consent, it’s through no fault of his own. He didn’t ask to be beamed up and have his memory erased and then brainwashed into thinking he’s Spock. Can he still be saved or is he lost in space? 24:02 – My question is: If a group of people were stranded on a deserted island, like in the TV show ‘Lost’, and there was no priest among them, could a lay person declare himself a priest and perform valid sacraments? Would the validity of the sacraments be contingent on how closely this person stuck to the teachings of the Church i.e. what if he had a suitcase full of Catholic books and was on his way to be ordained as a priest when the plane crashed? 33:38 – Seeing that “…the Lord opened the mouth of [Balaam’s] ass, and she said to Balaam, “What have I done to you, that you have struck me these three times?”…And the ass said to Balaam, “Am I not your ass, upon which you have ridden all your life long to this day? Was I ever accustomed to do so to you?”…..” (Num 22:28, 30) Did Balaam’s ass have a rational soul? 42:36 – Was it certain or contingent that Adam and Eve would fall or that the angels would fall? If it is certain, could God create other rational beings for whom their fall would be contingent and could they potentially persist perpetually in the state of grace and obedience to God? If it is contingent, could another human couple (same nature, different identity) have persisted in the state of grace and obedience to God perpetually in the Garden of Eden? For the angels, if they transcend space and time, how do we understand “before” and “after”, “in heaven” and “not in heaven” with respect to their fall? 49:54 – Suppose Middle-Earth really existed. Could God become incarnate as a man, an elf, a dwarf, and a hobbit all at the same time? If yes, could man, elf, dwarf, and hobbit Jesus interact with each other and maybe all go out for a pint? …

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello and welcome to Cat the Gances Live. I'm Psych hell at your host and if you're

0:20.3

not familiar with that movie, that movie, that music, that music signals that it's time

0:25.8

for some weird questions with Jimmy Akin. And if you haven't heard weird questions with

0:31.5

Jimmy Akin before, get ready because they got to reach a certain standard of weirdness

0:36.5

to make it. So we got two good hours of weird questions coming up and more of that music

0:41.5

to come. Jimmy Akin, Senior Apologist here at Catholic Answers and the proprietor of Jimmy

0:46.7

Akin's mysterious world. Hello Jimmy Akin. Hello Psych hell at. Hey, I wanted to thank you

0:52.1

for a great hour yesterday and also because it was very, very helpful in our fundraising. And the

1:00.3

day turned out to be just a wonderful day of fundraising and really redeemed what was looking

1:05.5

like a pretty tough pledge driving. It all worked out in the end. So thank you Jimmy.

1:10.6

I don't thank you. My pleasure. Happy to do it. And thank you to everybody who picked up

1:15.2

the phone and called or went to Catholic Answers radio.com and helped. It does seem like we're

1:20.9

going to come pretty close to our goal. I mean, there's people who make promises. I'll

1:26.2

send you a check in that kind of thing. So we're not exactly sure where we are. But after two days

1:31.3

where it looked like it was pretty much out of reach, you really came through for us yesterday.

1:36.2

So thank you, thank you, thank you. We're very, very grateful. And there was a lot of excitement

1:41.3

in the hallways here after two hours on air yesterday. All right. The weird questions, Jimmy,

1:47.6

come from all over, right? You get some of these weird questions. I guess some of them are emailed

1:51.2

to us. And if a person has a weird question and you can just email it to radio at Catholic.com,

1:58.3

we'll get it to Jimmy. And how have you rated these? Like how weird are we going today?

2:05.0

Well, there's a variety. I don't rape them. Okay. If something is not really weird at all,

2:12.2

I may move it over to a list of regular internet-informed questions. But most of them have at least

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catholic Answers, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catholic Answers and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.