meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Catholic Answers Live

#11128 Open Forum - Jimmy Akin

Catholic Answers Live

Catholic Answers

Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.82.2K Ratings

🗓️ 28 April 2023

⏱️ 55 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Questions Covered: 01:30 – While I was praying my rosary, it broke. Does this mean anything? 05:07 – Could 1 John 5:7 be used as evidence for the Trinity in scripture? 14:16 – How can I become an apologist? 18:40 – Why are the angels fighting in Revelation 12? And is that describing something current? 22:33 – How would you prove to a protestant that the woman in Genesis 3:15 is Mary? 29:53 – Does the Church have any literature on the topic of why men are leaders in the Church and the home? 35:13 – Is there historical evidence of dragons? Is it possible that they are what we currently think of as the dinosaurs? 45:23 – Is it required to have your first reconciliation before your first Communion? Are we supposed to have a CCD program at our parish for this? 48:32 – Is it better for an atheist to come to believe in some kind of God even if they don’t get all the way to the Christian God? …

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Welcome back to Catholic Ancestors Live. I am Psy Kellett, your host. So happy to be here on Thursday afternoon with Jimmy Aiken here having fun because it's open for him.

0:27.0

People can call and ask whatever they want to ask. Our age range today is from eight up. We haven't had anybody under eight yet, but that's just gives you an idea of open to anybody on any topic at all, eight, eight, three, one, eight, seven, eight, four.

0:44.0

I don't remember how we started, but discussing the time that they dropped the turkeys out of the helicopter on WKRP instance and added during the break.

0:52.0

The classic moments of television. We don't do those kind of promotions. I don't know if Catholic radio stations do promotions like that, but if you do, just remember turkeys can't fly.

1:06.0

Triple eight, 31 truth. Jimmy Aiken is our guest this hour. Jimmy Aiken is Senior Apologist here at Catholic Ancestors. And the author of so many things, including the Bible is a Catholic book, which we have already given away at least once this hour.

1:22.0

Your call is welcome. You got a Bible question. Jimmy's a great guy to ask a Bible question of eight, eight, eight, three, one, eight, seven, eight, four. Maybe you got a rosary question like Raquel does in Michigan watching on YouTube. Raquel, we're glad you're here. Go ahead with your question for Jimmy.

1:38.0

Thanks for taking my call. My question is I was pregnant rosary and during my prayer, the rosary just broke and I had the rosary blessed prior to using it. So it's fairly new and it just bothers me. Does this mean anything?

1:58.0

Well, let's find out if you can hear me because apparently I've been potted down and have been trying to comment, but was not able to. I can hear you now.

2:07.0

Yes, I see the sheepish look at someone's face. You were potted down. So Raquel, could your rosary breaking while you were praying, it means something, meaning beyond the fact that you would just use the rosary to the point that it broke.

2:26.0

Well, sure, it could, but in order to establish that now, this is like any paranormal investigation.

2:35.0

You got to look at the natural explanations first and only you need evidence if you want to claim that something unusual was happening here.

2:46.0

Now, people's rosaries break, especially after they've been using them for a long time, or if it's a shotally made rosary or whatever, you know, any material object will break.

2:58.0

So that is not of itself suspicious. The most likely time, in fact, for a rosary to break is when you're using it because you're, you know, you're pulling on it, you're tugging on it, you're

3:10.0

jostling the, let's say it was a chain link rosary, you're jostling the chain links and they might slip apart. So the most likely time for it to break is actually when you're using it.

3:22.0

If one wanted to propose that there was some special significance to it happening, I would need to see more evidence than just the fact that broke while it was being used.

3:33.0

For example, if it was correlated with something else that is more noteworthy, like, you know, I'm praying the rosary, it breaks and at the same moment lightning strikes or, and even that wouldn't prove it because you might be so started by the lightning strike that your fingers accidentally, you know, caused it to break.

3:58.0

Or maybe something else, like, you had just cursed the Virgin Mary and all of a sudden it broke, even that wouldn't prove it.

4:09.0

But I would need some kind of evidence beyond the mere fact it broke while it was being used in order to establish that it had any special significance.

4:20.0

So let me ask you, Raquel, have was it correlated with any other unusual events?

4:28.0

It was not.

4:30.0

Okay, then I would say that the most likely explanation, I can't prove this because, you know, we don't have access to the invisible world, but I would say that the most likely explanation is it broke through purely natural causes because it was getting to a point where either, you know,

4:50.0

where the chain links were a little loose and they finally came apart or something else.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catholic Answers, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catholic Answers and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.