meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast

What If Jesus Is Just One More Myth? Inside a Homicide Detective's Spiritual Crime Scene

The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast

ColdCaseChristianity.com

Philosophy, Society & Culture, Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.81.5K Ratings

🗓️ 29 April 2026

⏱️ 46 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

In this episode, cold-case homicide detective and Christian apologist J. Warner Wallace walks through the "spiritual crime scene" of his own journey from skeptical naturalist to follower of Jesus. Drawing on decades of investigative experience, he explains why the usual reasons people give for being Christians ("I was raised this way" or "I had an experience") are not uniquely Christian, and why the real question is whether the Gospels record what actually happened in the first century. You'll hear how eyewitness variation in the Gospel accounts first caught his attention, how the standard jury instructions for testing witnesses can be applied to the New Testament, and why abductive reasoning from four key facts about Jesus points most reasonably to the resurrection. J. Warner also unpacks his memorable distinction between "belief that" and "belief in," using a bulletproof vest story from an officer-involved shooting to show what genuine, evidence-based trust in Christ looks like when the stakes are life and death. Along the way, he addresses miracles in other world religions, the rising generational question "Is Christianity good and worth caring about?", and the power of God-honoring content to reshape our culture.

If this conversation helped you think more clearly about Jesus, take a moment to subscribe so you never miss an episode. And if you'd be willing to leave a rating and review in your podcast app, it really helps more people discover the show and join the conversation about the case for Christianity.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Welcome to the Cold Case Christianity podcast, where a veteran cold case homicide detective investigates the truth of the Christian worldview. Jay Warner Wallace is a dateline featured detective, Christian apologist, and bestselling author. This weekly show applies real investigative tools to the claims of Christianity. Thanks for joining us with the Cold Case Christianity Podcast.

0:21.6

I'm Jay Warner Wallace.

0:23.1

I haven't done this in a while where I've actually just played an interview I did,

0:27.1

but this interview I thought came out so well in the sense of the kinds of questions I got

0:31.5

in the second half of the interview that I hope is as helpful to you as well.

0:36.2

This is really a weekly thing they do where they

0:39.6

kind of do and ask the expert, and we were the last hour of this show for this particular week.

0:46.7

And I've done interviews with Carl before. He's super animated, knows a lot about Christian

0:51.3

apologetics, is really interested in Christian apologetics. But a lot of his callers are just regular folks who are like, hey, how do I, I need to be better

0:58.4

at this. How do I get better at it? So I'm hoping that this conversation, well, number one,

1:02.9

I hope model how you might quickly, if you only got 30 seconds to a minute to answer a question,

1:08.9

even the questions that Carl asked in the beginning.

1:11.9

Hopefully that will model that for you. So here's my interview from this morning, actually,

1:16.6

with Carl and Crew. It's Carl and Crew. We are in our final hour of Ask the Experts.

1:23.0

Got Jay Warner Wallace here. How you doing, Jay Warner? Doing well. This is the last hour. Wow.

1:28.9

I feel like this is... You're capping it. You're capping it. And yeah, we are really honored to have you with us here.

1:35.6

All right, my man. Let's build some context. Give us your story. You were out there far from God, weren't you?

1:42.6

Yeah, and I was not really interested. I didn't have anybody

1:44.6

in my family who were Christians. And I, and I think it was, sadly, I hate to admit this,

1:50.0

but the people I knew that were Christians at my job as a detective were interestingly not

1:56.7

evidential about their Christian views. Well, of course, our job requires us to be evidential about everything else. So these are guys who can make a case for so many different bad guys we were trying to catch. Yet, but if you asked them, well, can you make a case for this? They seem like that even the idea seemed foreign. Like, this is not something they would need to make a case for. And I was somebody who said, look, if you can't make a case for it, that I'm not interested, right? That's silly. Why do you think that was? And so I would often mock those guys. Why do you think that was? Why did they not see the congruency of their faith with their cold case detective work? Well, I think a lot of it is, if you look at scripture, there's, and I see this all around the country that if you ask people, why are you a Christian? The top three answers you're going to get are number one. I was raised as a Christian. My family are Christians. My parents were Christians. That's the most popular answer you're going to get. Number two is going to be something along the lines of.

2:52.3

I had an experience, and that experience confirmed for me this is true.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from ColdCaseChristianity.com, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of ColdCaseChristianity.com and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.