Versailles Introduction Part 3/3

When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

Zack Twamley

Phd, International Relations, Korean War, European History, 17th Century, 18th Century, Politics, 20th Century, Thirty Years' War, History, 19th Century, War, First World War

4.8 • 773 Ratings

🗓️ 13 November 2018

⏱️ 41 minutes

🔗️ Recording | iTunes | RSS

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Another introduction episode - this one giving us a brief(ish) rundown on the origins of the Great War, for the benefit of those that have not listened to the July Crisis Anniversary Project of old. The world went to war in 1914, and the circumstances which surround that event are often held against Germany in the subsequent peace negotiations. Germany, it is said, started the whole wretched thing, so she should be punished once her gamble failed, and she clearly lost. In my view though, it isn't that simple.

Historians tend to take one side or the other when it comes to examining the July Crisis and Treaty of Versailles. By that I mean, either Germany started the war and deserved the Treaty, or she didn't start it or deserve it. I won't be this clear cut, because the situation and the debate aren't this clear cut. In my mind, Germany alone did not start the war - even though technically she did declare war on Russia first and begin the countdown - but she did deserve some kind of punishment for LOSING it.

Germany, as my thesis for this project will argue, was punished for losing the Great War, not for starting it.

Any statesman worth their salt in 1918-19 knew full well that there was more to the story than the straightforward tale of the belligerent Hun. Germany had to be punished and kept low so that she could not threaten the peace again, and because of her military loss, this meant that she was liable to be punished - just as Berlin had punished her enemies in Russia and Romania, and developed grand plans for punishing Britain and France before her war plans collapsed. The issue with Versailles wasn't so much the injustice of it, as we will learn, but the problem of making Germany accept its terms, when Germans came to believe that they hadn't been truly beaten, hadn't truly started the war, and had been unfairly blamed.

Yet, an important point to remember is that war guilt - another issue we will deal with in time - did not have to exist in Germany in order for the judgement of Germany's contemporaries to follow. It did not matter, in other words, who started the war, as much as it mattered who lost it, and what was to be done next. This episode will help us refocus our gaze on that critical issue, and also ensure that we're all on the same page when it comes to my thesis and ideas about the origins of the First World War. As always, I'd ask you guys keep an open mind - we'll be sticking together for the next eight months, so you better get used to my outside the box way of thinking!

*****************

The Versailles Anniversary Project is possible because of your support and interest - make sure to spread the word, engage with the debate, and look at the different ways you can help this project succeed!

Visit the homeland for this new project:

http://www.wdfpodcast.com/vap/

Support the podcast financially:

https://www.patreon.com/WhenDiplomacyFails

Follow WDF on Twitter!

https://twitter.com/wdfpodcast

Get bonus content on Patreon

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0	Three thousand miles from home, an American army is fighting for you.
0:18.0	To the end, it's the high ideals for which America stands may endure upon the earth.
0:30.5	I earnestly intrigued my countrymen to pause before they rush Hitler into this revolutionary change, which may well be irretrievable.
0:51.0	I know that it is hard for Americans to realize the magnitude of the war in which we are involved.
0:59.6	France and Italy, between them have made waste people in the peace of the nation's relationships
1:07.2	that in fairness confusion, if it are to the world, can be set straight all by the permit and most
1:13.6	determined exhibition of the will to leave and make the right to avail.
1:18.6	We're here because we're here because we're here because we're here because we're here, because we're here. You are listening to the Versailles Anniversary Project.
1:56.6	Introduction part three.
2:02.9	A simple Google search of why did World War I happen
2:08.1	yields some 9.7 million results, all of which vary in accuracy and accessibility.
2:15.4	Something which nearly all of these resulting explanations do say, though,
2:19.4	is a phrase which, while simple on paper, tells us a great deal about the topic as a whole.
2:25.4	The outbreak of the Great War, these sources note, is a subject which remains controversial to this day.
2:33.6	Controversial? How can something which occurred over a century ago still be
2:37.3	controversial? To add to that, how can a question which concerns powers that no longer exist
2:43.7	still be in any way contentious? Comparing it to other key events or incidents in world history
2:49.8	suggests that maybe historians
2:52.2	or laypeople care more about the outbreak of the Great War than they should. Isn't it time to move
2:58.2	on? That's the thing, though. There is no debate like that, which revolves around the eruption
3:04.5	of the Great War because there never has been and there never will be anything like the Great War ever again.
3:10.1	28th century history is so often consumed by the image of one man, Adolf Hitler, and the crimes he perpetuated,
	...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Previous episode | Next episode

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Zack Twamley, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Zack Twamley and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.