There were two more murders, 15 miles away.

When police arrived, they found the telephones and electricity lines.

We have a weird homicide.

A scene described by one investigator as reminiscent of a weird...

He said she said can make any case difficult.

What happens when there is a case with conflicting physical evidence and two men involved

who both have very different stories? Between December 23rd and 24th, 1980, a woman was attacked

inside of her home and murdered by two men that she knew. And though they were brought to trial for

the crime, it's difficult to determine what

actually happened that night. So if you like your coffee hot but your bones chilled, sit back and

start your day with a morning cup of murder. Annie Orr, an 86-year-old widow living alone, was

fast asleep in her Montevallo, Alabama home on the evening of December 23, 1980.

The holidays were just a few days away, and I can imagine she closed her eyes for the night, peacefully anticipating time with her family.

Instead, she was woken up by a blow to her body with a blunt object. Two men had

broken into her house and repeatedly raped, beat, and suffocated her to death as December 23rd became

Christmas Eve. She was left with a pillowcase taped around her head, the tape ultimately

leading to her slow asphyxiation. The two assailants

left the woman to die as they grabbed any money and valuables that they could find. Since she

lived through the rape and assault, they could hear the elderly woman, a woman they knew,

begging for them to take whatever they wanted in exchange for her life. She pleaded with them until she

took her last breath. When police found the crime scene, they also found a trail of playing

cards that led straight to the home of 18-year-old Victor Kennedy, a petty criminal who did

...