Top 10 NFL Sports Card GOATS, MLB Prospects Heating Up, Non-QBs to Make a Splash

Sports Cards Nonsense

Hobbies, Leisure

4.5 • 1K Ratings

🗓️ 2 September 2025

⏱️ 65 minutes

🔗️ Recording | iTunes | RSS

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Mike Gioseffi and Jesse Gibson are joined by Papa Gio to break down their Top 10 NFL quarterbacks of all time, through the lens of sports cards. From refusing to debate Tom Brady to weighing in on Patrick Mahomes, Peyton Manning, and Aaron Rodgers, the guys explain their rankings and look at recent card sales for each QB. They also spotlight the most underrated NFL sports card GOATs, highlighting players whose cardboard still deserves more love. In hobby news, they cover: Why you shouldn’t get swayed by recent record-breaking sales MLB prospect chatter featuring Red Sox pitcher Payton Tolle and Mets pitcher Jonah Tong A mailbag on non-quarterbacks who could make a splash this NFL season Plus, a reminder: don’t buy what you don’t understand. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0	As they say in Europe, some European countries, the EU, the band is back together again.
0:14.9	Jesse is back from New York.
0:16.4	We're going to talk about that trip, riveting open right there, little tease.
0:20.0	We have me and Papagio's top 10 quarterback list. I didn't get the invite to give a that trip. Rivening open right there. Little tease. We have me and Papa Gio's top
0:21.2	10 quarterback list. I didn't get the invite to give a top 10. You don't want my top 10? I do want it. I see, I feel bad because generally I'm the one with a bad memory. We did talk about this when Tim was here. I said, hey, the Monday when we're back, Papa Gio, top 10 NFL. Oh, yeah.
0:34.7	Do you know 10?
0:35.8	Do I know 10 quarterbacks?
0:36.8	He knows 10 quarterbacks.
0:37.6	Top 10 quarterbacks are my thing.
0:39.6	Why New York sucks.
0:40.8	Top 10 quarterbacks? He knows 10 quarters. Top 10 quarterbacks are my thing. Why New York sucks. Top 10 quarterbacks. Top 10 all time. All right. So praise for Panini. There's your open. Praise for Panini. And then two elite hobby pitchers. I also have some gem rate info. It's one thing I wanted to touch on that. Jam Ray can go die.
0:55.2	Jim rate's great.
0:58.1	Wasn't that guy on the show once? Yeah, he was nice. He was very good.
1:03.6	New York City is a topic number one. New York City sucks. Yes, he goes. Is a cesspool.
1:13.4	And I just mean that in the nicest way. So, and this is coming from someone who is also very jaded because we stayed not even a block off of Times Square near the Sabaros. Is that still there? There's a Sabaro over there. Oh, there's
1:18.1	a Sabaro. There's also diseases. There's vomit and urine everywhere. The homeless population's out
1:25.5	of control. And it's just nonstop people. If you have any
1:29.8	issue with just being surrounded at all times, not the place you want to be. That being said,
1:36.5	went to other parts in New York, downtown further, went over to the World Trade Center thing. We did
1:42.5	the edge. They're not there anymore.
1:45.9	There's one World Trade Center.
1:46.5	That's very good. Is there a monument built? It's just a skyscraper now. It's just one. There's going to be two, actually. But it's one world. Really? Yeah. So it's, we went up to the top of that. That was very, very cool. 24th anniversary next week, by the way.
	...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Previous episode | Next episode

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Sports Cards Nonsense, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Sports Cards Nonsense and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.