Evan Roberts.

Tiki Barber.

It's Evan and Tiki on WFAN, The Fan, 1019 FM, and always live on the free Odyssey app.

Welcome in to a very special edition of Evidentiki live from American Dream.

Brought to you by Modelo, an official Cervesa of the New York Giants.

We will get to the Giants and the Eagles.

But this show we're about to do is a very familiar show.

It's a show we do every single year.

And it's a challenging show.

It's the show where a season is over.

And to me, there are three parts to a day like today.

There's what the hell happened, there's who do we blame, and there's what to do next.

We need to start with what happened, and the first thing I'll do, Teak, is I will raise my hand and say, what happened last

night really surprised me. And baseball usually doesn't surprise you, because baseball is meant to be

surprises. So why would something surprise you when you're expecting surprises, if that makes sense?

I did not think that the Toronto Blue Jay Bullpen in a bullpen game would shut down the New York Yankee offense.

I didn't say it to reverse jinx you.

I didn't say it because for any reason other than I thought these bats would destroy these arms.

And I sat there at Yankee Stadium last night to the bitter end.

A lot of you people did not, including Sean, which we'll get to.

And as we sit here,

you know, 14 hours later, that's where I've got to start. I know there's a lot of other things about last night's game and the season as a whole, but they didn't hit Louis Varland, Mason Flewhardy,

...