meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The CRUX: True Survival Stories

The Vanishing at Pendleton Mountain | Disaster Strikes E221

The CRUX: True Survival Stories

Bleav + Kaycee McIntosh + Julie Henningsen

Society & Culture, Halloween, Wilderness, True Crime, Nature, National, Crime, Documentary

4.0 β€’ 606 Ratings

πŸ—“οΈ 12 March 2026

⏱️ 28 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

In 1988, a Chicago sportswriter left everything behind to write a novel in a tiny Colorado mountain town β€” and then vanished without a trace the same week investigators found the body of the mysterious man who'd occupied his storefront the year before. Over 200 searchers, 18 dogs, and a fatal plane crash later, Keith Reinhard was never found β€” and the question of what really happened still has no answer.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

You know what's worse than being stranded on a mountain with no food?

0:03.9

Uh, listening to ads when you're trying to escape reality? Exactly. That's why we've got

0:09.8

you covered on Patreon. For just a few bucks, ditch the ads completely. And for a few bucks more,

0:16.3

get ad-free listening plus early access to our disaster strikes episodes. Because when disaster

0:22.6

hits in the middle of nowhere, you'll want the story first. Head to patreon.com and search

0:29.0

Crux True Survival Stories. Your future survival depends on it. Okay, maybe not literally,

0:35.8

but your listening experience definitely will.

0:40.7

Welcome to the segment of the Crux podcast called Disaster Strikes. While our regular episodes

0:46.6

focus on survival stories where people overcome incredible odds, this biweekly segment examines

0:52.6

outdoor adventures that ended in tragedy.

0:56.0

These stories are meant to paint a clear picture of how quickly things can go wrong in the

1:00.4

wilderness and the cascade of decisions, often small and seemingly reasonable in the moment,

1:06.2

that can lead to devastating outcomes. By studying these incidents respectfully and thoroughly, we can all learn

1:13.3

valuable lessons that might save lives. The stories are difficult, but the education they provide

1:19.3

is invaluable. Today, we're taking you to a small mountain town where the line between fiction

1:25.7

and reality became fatally blurred.

1:31.9

In the summer of 1988, Keith Reinhart ran a small storefront in Silver Plume, Colorado,

1:40.3

population 130. By then, his hair had gone wild, long and gray. He'd grown a beard.

1:48.1

At 49 years old, friends said he looked like a different person, like a man who'd been wandering.

1:55.3

The shop sold antiques, photographs, things people left behind. But no one could see what was inside that building.

2:02.8

On a desk next to a computer, the unfinished novel that would become Keith's epitaph.

2:09.8

The last line he ever wrote was this. Guy Gypsum changed into some hiking boots and

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Bleav + Kaycee McIntosh + Julie Henningsen, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Bleav + Kaycee McIntosh + Julie Henningsen and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright Β© Tapesearch 2026.