May 15th, 1930 Chicago, Illinois

After a newspaper ad is placed asking for assistance for the poverty-stricken family of two-year-old Mary Agnes Moroni, a woman

named Julia Otis shows up at their home to help.

She offers to take Mary Agnes shopping to buy her some new clothes, but they never return.

22 years later, a woman named Mary McClelland comes forward

after suspecting that she might be Mary Agnes,

and experts conclude that she is probably the missing child.

However, after Mary McLellan passes away in 2005, DNA testing shows no genetic connection between her and the Moroni family.

After that, the trail went cold. Oh, uh, yeah. Oh, uh, uh, uh, uh, and uh, and uh, uh, uh, uh,

uh, uh, and uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, okay.

Oh, uh, okay. Hello everyone and welcome to the latest episode of the Trail went cold.

I'm your host Robin Warder and today we will be jumping back 87 years to profile the oldest

cold case we've ever featured on this podcast, the 1930 disappearance of two-year-old Mary Agnes Moroni.

This is actually the first mystery we've covered involving a missing infant

since those cases are incredibly heartbreaking.

However, this story is pretty unique because it was seemingly solved two decades later, but a stunning

revelation in recent years has turned it into an unsolved cold case again. You might be familiar with the story of Bobby Dunbar, a four-year-old boy who disappeared

in 1912 and was the subject of a very famous episode of the podcast, This American Life. A boy resembling Bobby was found in

another state eight months later and even though another woman insisted that he

was her child, the boy was returned to the Dunbar family. He lived the rest of his life as Bobby Dunbar, but several

decades after his death, DNA testing proved that he had no genetic connection to the Dunbar family and that a horrible mistake had been made.

Today's story about Mary Agnes Moroni is fairly similar and while it's less well known than the Bobby Dunbar case,

...