On the morning of June 16, 2012,

Aubrey Lee Price boards a flight to Atlanta

and then another flight to Key West.

His family thinks that he's on his way to Guatemala for business,

that he'll be home soon, but it's all a lie.

In Key West, he goes to the post office

and drops a letter in the mail.

And then he disappears,

leaving every indication that he has gone for good.

And the bartender, she said, have you seen the news?

And so I get on my phone,

I start scrolling through the news

and complete shock, complete shock.

Just, I mean, didn't see it coming.

Aubrey Lee Price was a small town pastor,

turned hedge fund manager, turned missing person.

His friends described him as kind and humble.

Someone who took his faith seriously

and always looked out for those around him.

But he had convinced members of his church

to invest their entire life savings into his hedge fund.

So what happened to make him suddenly disappear

...