I'm Andrea Canning, and what makes this story so remarkable to me is that it spans two

different date line episodes I covered.

Our prime suspect in this story was actually considered a hero in another one.

He spoke to me about the case, and something he said will go down as one of the strangest

responses I've ever heard.

As I was talking to him, it really made me wonder if someone who could be so caring could

also be so evil.

Here's the Night of the New Moon.

It was dark when it happened.

So dark, astronomers have a name for it.

The Night of the New Moon.

When the moon, the sun, and the earth are all in alignment, and the lunar cycle begins

a new.

Some look at a new moon as a time of rebirth, a fresh start.

And only the people we trust here on Earth were as dependable as the night sky.

There's a guy lying down like a sniper.

We saw that in the garden.

And he's trying to get his life to pick this up at the time.

Carl's bag, California, an affluent seaside community in northern San Diego County.

A tourist haven known for its beaches, surfing, and breathtaking views.

This paradise became home to a woman named Diana Lovejoy.

She's just really funny and silly and smart and really easy to talk to.

...