This audio is brought to you by MuslimCentral.com

Sister Sadia from California emails saying that she wishes to perform the hedge

But her situation does not allow her to have a maharam traveling with her and so she is aware of the controversies over a

Lady traveling without the maharam she is saying that she's going to go in the standard packages of hedge for an America that go in large groups and

Obviously she's aware that people say it's haram and it's not and it's and it's halal

She just wants my opinion and to summarize the the the differing views in this regard

So

So our sister Sadia is well aware that this is nothing new. This is a standard age-old controversy goes back 1,200 years

And in our times it has been rekindled because obviously of the changes of the the the the realities of the worlds that we live in

And this controversy

It has been manifested in many of the Q&A that I'm doing throughout this series

And that is the the notion of if we understand the cause of a ruling

Does the ruling still apply or not and this is a very common controversy from the beginning of time

Okay, if we understand why something has been

Not the wisdom because that's something else Hickman something else if we understand the cause if we understand the reason

That a particular ruling has been given then if that cause no longer exists

Can the ruling be made lacks and this is I've done many Q&A that I've gone over this back and forth

And I have spoken about this reality that from the time of the Sahaba we had

What we can call the more literalist streak if the Hedy says it that's it no if Sanser butts about it

And we have those that are more

Thinking about the goals of the Shariah right and again this this tension exists

It's not quite it is a type of tension

...