I was shocked.

Things just didn't add up.

It was the last place you'd expect to find

a gruesome crime scene.

The quiet neighborhood, the lovely home,

this friendly couple.

I think it's hard not to have loved Amy.

They were very happy, very happy.

It seemed to be a simple case of a robbery, gone horribly wrong.

He realized that she was dead or dying.

But nothing about this case was simple.

Not the marriage and not the murders.

You just kept getting more red flags come up.

The surprises just kept on coming.

He said, you know, you can't talk to him privately.

What dark force claimed two lives?

I feel like she's still there.

I still feel her with me.

Life seems to move just a little slower in South Carolina.

Afternoons in Colombia can be spent on the meandering Saluda River

or nearby Lake Murray.

And tucked away inside this capital city is Ascoda States,

...