For nearly 40 years, Kathleen Flynn's murder has haunted Norwalk, Connecticut.

She was 11 years old, newly in middle school, walking home on a familiar path when she was attacked and killed.

Her case became one of the state's most well-known cold cases, the kind people never stopped talking about, and the kind investigators

kept returning to as forensic science moved forward. In 2019, after decades of waiting, police

finally made an arrest, and in 2026, it looked like Kathy's family might finally see the case reach a verdict.

But then, just days into trial, a single email threatened to undo that long-awaited

progress. Now the question is no longer just what happened to Kathy, but what happens next? I'm Kylie Lowe and this is the case of Kathleen Flynn on Dark Down East. On Tuesday, September 23, 1986, the school day at Powness Ridge Middle School in Norwalk, Connecticut,

ended the same way it always did, with the 240 bell.

Students spilled out into the hallways, some headed for buses, some went on to after-school

activities. Outside, the soccer and field hockey teams were practicing on the fields, and 11-year-old

Kathleen Marie Flynn, who usually went by Kathy, went to her locker and organized some papers

inside before she packed up her white duffel bag and left school for the day.

Kathy was only a few weeks into her middle school career and she'd started walking home from school

that fall. It was short, only about a half mile from Powness Ridge Middle School to her house on

Kendall Court. And like a lot of kids in the neighborhood, she took the shortcut through the

wooded area behind the school, a paved footpath that cut from campus to Hunter's Lane.

Most days, Kathy walked that path with a few friends, but that afternoon she was alone.

According to reporting by Marissa Alter for News 12, one friend had gotten a ride home and another

was homesick from school. Kathy was supposed to meet her mother, Esther Flynn, at a nearby

intersection by 3.30 that day. They had plans that afternoon to go shopping for a new purse

for Kathy. Esther was running a little late, but not by much.

When she got to the meeting spot, Kathy wasn't there.

...