Firefighters arrived to a fully involved house fire. You can only imagine just what they've gone through and the tragedy that they've suffered. And you find a piece of evidence this fire was intentional. Your natural question is, well, who is that person? Who has the motivation to do this?

I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anasiga Nikolazi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation discoveries true conviction.

And this is Anatomy of Murph.

Binghamton, New York is home to one of the state's best universities.

But for those who live there full time,

it's also a tight-knit city filled with familiar faces.

And that made the heartbreaking events here even harder to imagine.

A devastating fire that destroyed a community's sense of safety.

The only path to healing was to bring the perpetrator to justice. It was the job of Broome County Chief Assistant DA Lucas Findlay, a job he prepared for his whole life.

My plan was to go into law enforcement, but in a different avenue.

I wanted to become a state trooper, but the New York State Police were in, I believe, an eight-year hiring freeze.

It kind of boxed me in and made me think of other alternatives. And I decided, hey, maybe I'll

go to law school. And I ended up doing this because it gives you a sense of doing good for your

community and keeping people safe. Lucas Finley clearly took his job with the desire to serve his community, and he is

diligent, caring, and committed to getting the truth, and that made this case incredibly

challenging.

It involved a crime that shattered a family and devastated a neighborhood.

The date was March 17, 2011.

There was a report called in by numerous people in the city of Binghamton that there was a

structure fire, a residential fire in the area of 21 Milford Street in the city of Binghamton

here in New York. It was observed around 3 or 3.30 initially.

...