meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Gray Area with Sean Illing

The core contradiction of American politics

The Gray Area with Sean Illing

Vox Media Podcast Network

Society & Culture, News, Politics, News Commentary, Philosophy

4.610.8K Ratings

🗓️ 11 February 2019

⏱️ 64 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

The Republican and Democratic parties are not the same. I’ll say it again: The Republican and Democratic parties are not the same. I don’t just mean they believe different things. I mean they’re composed in different ways, they argue from different premises, they’re structured in different ways. We treat them as mirror images of each other — the left and right hands of American politics — but they’re not. And the ways in which they’re different make it hard for them to understand each other, and hard for American politics to function. Political scientists Matt Grossmann and Dan Hopkins literally wrote the book on how the parties are different. In Asymmetric Politics: Ideological Republicans and Group Interest Democrats, they argue that the differences between the parties stem from a central and longstanding split in the country’s political personality: We are a country of philosophical conservatives, and policy liberals. We want a small government that does more of everything. I asked Grossmann on the show to walk me through the ways the parties are different, and how those differences explain everything from the GOP’s repeated shutdowns to asymmetric polarization to the rise of Fox News. This is a conversation about the fundamental structure of America’s parties, public opinion, and media institutions. It’s worth the time. Book Recommendations: Racial Realignment: The Transformation of American Liberalism, 1932-1965by Eric Schickler Before the Storm: Barry Goldwater and the Unmaking of the American Consensusby Rick Perlstein Law and Order: Street Crime, Civil Unrest, and the Crisis of Liberalism in the 1960's by Michael W. Flamm Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

When you drive a Chevy electric vehicle, you're getting more than a way to get from point A to point B.

0:06.0

You're saying goodbye to gas stations and hello to open roads.

0:10.0

With the growing network of public charging stations, you'll be able to charge your EV while you shop, work, or do whatever you want to be doing with your time.

0:17.0

Chevy is making EVs for everyone, everywhere. Go to chevrelay.com slash electric to learn more.

0:24.0

There are conservative parties everywhere, but the Republican party is the only party in the world that hasn't reconciled itself to the rise of the welfare state and the regulatory state.

0:39.0

Hello, welcome to Mr. Glanch on the Vox Media podcast network. A couple of weeks ago, I asked for ideas on people to interview about polarization and identities.

0:59.0

In particular, the ways that the Republican party and the Democratic party are fundamentally different from each other.

1:04.0

Why have forces that are affecting both led to very different outcomes? Why did the Republican party nominate Donald Trump in 2016, where as a Democratic party went with a much more traditional candidate?

1:16.0

Why does Republican parties seem to prefer shutdowns and seem to be more polarized both in tactics and ideology than the Democratic party has become? What's behind that?

1:25.0

The expert on this is a guy named Matt Grossman, who along with Dan Hopkins, both of them, political scientists, wrote a really fantastic book, a couple years back called asymmetric politics, ideological or Republicans and group interest Democrats.

1:38.0

And it's about the fundamental differences in the two parties, coalitions, the way those coalitions look at the world and how those differences explain what we see all around us today.

1:50.0

Grossman, he's got a political science podcast called political research digest with the Nyskinen center. He is really, really, I don't usually recommend people's Twitter feeds, but I really do recommend his. I think it is maybe the best way to follow new developments and new papers in political science.

2:05.0

But this is very much a conversation trying to help me and hopefully you think through what is really different in the Democratic and Republican parties?

2:14.0

Why have they acted and operated in different ways in this era and how fundamental are those differences? I'm not sure I am bought into every piece of Matt's theory, but I think it is really the starting point for trying to understand this topic.

2:27.0

And so I hope you enjoy it. My email is always as a client show at box.com. Here is Matt Grossman.

2:34.0

Matt Grossman, welcome to the podcast. Thank you. I got to be here. So why are Democrats and Republicans so different? Are they?

2:41.0

Let's ask a big question. Let's go right to it.

2:44.0

I think there is a long standing set of differences between the Republicans and Democrats. And we, my co-author David Hopkins and I started kind of listing them.

2:53.0

And we decided that they really amounted to one sort of global difference that the Republican Party is a vehicle of a symbolic ideological movement, whereas the Democratic Party is a coalition of social groups.

3:06.0

And there are incentives for each party to kind of continue on their traditional way. Republican leaders by attracting loyalty to eternal values and reactions to social change and Democratic leaders by seeking concrete government action through kind of a catalog of specific policies to respond to each of the group identities in their coalition.

3:31.0

And so I want to push us because I think this is both a very interesting definition of it. And I want to understand where the boundaries of it really are.

3:38.0

So how do you distinguish an ideological coalition from a social group coalition? I look at the Republican Party and I know a lot of people talk a big game about limited government and so on.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Vox Media Podcast Network, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Vox Media Podcast Network and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.