meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Notes from America with Kai Wright

The Case for 29 Supreme Court Justices

Notes from America with Kai Wright

WNYC Studios

News Commentary, Politics, History, News

4.41.5K Ratings

🗓️ 20 July 2023

⏱️ 18 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

We’re gonna need a bigger bench. Because when most people talk about expanding the Supreme Court, they're talking about adding a few justices. But Elie Mystal is not most people. He thinks we should just blow the lid and add 20 justices. Here's why.

This is from Contempt of Court, a new podcast from Elie and The Nation. This episode is called "Elie's Court Packing Plan." Also, heads up that Elie drops the F-bomb in this episode.

Send us your song for our summer playlist project! What’s a song that represents your personal diaspora story? Go to notesfromamerica.org and click on the “RECORD” button to leave a voice note with your answer. Tell us the name of that song and the artist, and a 1-minute story that goes along with it. We’ll gather all of the songs and your stories in a Spotify playlist that we’ll update all summer.

Tell us what you think. Instagram and Twitter: @noteswithkai. Email us at notes@wnyc.org. Send us a voice message by recording yourself on your phone and emailing us, or going to Instagram and clicking on the link in our bio.

“Notes from America” airs live on Sunday evenings at 6pm ET. The podcast episodes are lightly edited from our live broadcasts. Tune into the show on Sunday nights via the stream on notesfromamerica.org.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hey, this is Kai. I want to share something that got my mind churning in an unexpected

0:14.2

way recently. We've of course had a lot of conversations on this show about the Supreme

0:19.1

Court and its impact on our society. And in those conversations, we have often turned

0:24.9

to my friend and colleague, Ellie Mistal. He's the Justice Correspondent for the Nation

0:29.7

Magazine and author of the book Allow Me to Retort a Black Guys Guide to the Constitution.

0:36.9

And he is unapologetic about his belief that the Supreme Court has way too much power

0:44.0

and has caused way too much harm to just leave that power unchecked. Ellie is an advocate

0:51.6

for the kind of big bold reforms that many liberals and certainly many democratic elected

0:59.2

officials have rejected because they feel like they're too much, too fast, too radical.

1:06.9

Anyway, Ellie has a new podcast. It's called Contemptive Court. It's aptly named. And

1:12.7

in it, he's breaking down some of these bold ideas that he's got for reigning in the court.

1:19.4

And I want to share a short episode in which Ellie goes deep on one of those ideas that

1:25.2

he's brought to our show previously, which is packing the court with more justices. Now

1:31.0

court packing is itself controversial, but Ellie's version takes the idea and runs to

1:36.2

what at first might sound like an absurdist extreme. But when I hear him out, I'm actually

1:44.0

caught off guard by how practical the idea is. I mean, how it's really kind of just making

1:51.8

the court function, how the rest of the judiciary already functions. So enough for me coming

1:58.3

up, I'm going to let Ellie make the case himself. And at some point, we'll have him back

2:02.4

on notes from America to dissect this idea further. After the break, Ellie moustalls

2:08.4

court packing plan. When most people talk about expanding the Supreme Court, they're talking

2:26.4

about adding a few justices to or for to the bench. But I am not most people. I do not

2:34.0

think we should add a few justices to get into an endless tit for tat with Mitch McConnell

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from WNYC Studios, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of WNYC Studios and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.