The following podcast contains dramatizations of actual events.

Certain situations, dialogue, names, and locations may have been changed.

Some scenes are graphic in nature.

Listener discretion is advised. Up next, the way this fire burned has even experts wondering what happened.

Fire did not behave in a manner that appeared to be typical.

A body is found, but something about it confounds investigators.

The position of his body to me seemed a little unusual from what I'd experienced

in other fatalities.

It raised questions of, well, was he already deceased from some reason?

Was there some kind of a medical situation.

If it's murder, how was the victim killed?

And if this is murder, can detectives prove it? So, Every fall in Morgantown, West Virginia, home of West Virginia University, football

reigns supreme. On Monday, November 28, 2005, the city was still reveling in a recent victory over the University

of Pittsburgh in the so-called backyard brawl, one of the oldest rivalries in college sports.

But celebrations by local firefighters didn't last long.

That morning, they were called to a fire in a suburban neighborhood.

We heard on the radio that fire in a suburban neighborhood.

We heard on the radio that there was a structure fire

on Kill Arnie Drive, which was in the north section of the city,

in the city of Morgantown.

Firefighters were met at the scene by a man named Bobby Teats.

He identified himself as a friend of the family that owned the home.

...