meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Evan & Tiki

Shaun vs Craig: Evan Drops the Trust Poll and Jets Fans Explode

Evan & Tiki

Audacy

Sports

4.2988 Ratings

🗓️ 4 February 2026

⏱️ 23 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Evan tries to calm the Carton vs Morash noise by admitting he respects both, then throws gasoline on it anyway by posting the ultimate Twitter poll: who do you trust more, Craig Carton or Shaun Morash? The guys break down the voting blocs, Mets fans still angry about the Kyle Tucker saga, Jets fans furious at Morash, and the “swing states” that decide the whole thing. Early returns come in and Shaun is actually winning, which turns into a hilarious reality check on what it even means to be in a trust poll with a Radio Hall of Famer. The calls keep it moving, the Jets credibility debate keeps boiling, and then the show pivots to the night in New York sports: the Knicks crush the Wizards and keep their win streak alive, the Nets get run off the floor by the Lakers, and the Islanders finally grab a win in a wild one. Plus, a quick laugh at Big Mac refusing to run the poll, some family fandom warfare, and then the focus shifts to what’s next for the Knicks with the NBA trade deadline looming and Ian Begley joining to break it all down.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

The extremist, Sean's a jet-hating troll who bathes in his own poo.

0:04.9

And Craig is a jet chill, right? So I love both guys. I have a great respect for Craig Carton, and I love you too, Sean. So there's no biases. Oh, I'm on this show or that. No, I love both of you. Thank you. Yeah, I'm sure. I bathe in my own poo. You love me. But I just put out a poll on my Twitter account at Evan Roberts, WFN, maybe my greatest poll.

0:25.7

I'm going to let the people decide. Who do you trust more?

0:28.7

And I offer no information, no inside, no biases, who do you trust more, Craig Carton or Sean Morash?

0:36.2

Now, before we check the results throughout the program,

0:39.3

I'll tell you what's going to hurt Craig and help Sean and vice versa.

0:43.9

Craig is going to be damaged by Met fans who are pissed off about Kyle Tucker.

0:47.8

Like they are holding him accountable going on the radio a few weeks ago and saying,

0:52.2

eh, it's a done deal or whatever he said.

0:54.0

Right or wrong. So that will hurt Craig. But Jet fans, Sean, don't like you. I'm the bad guy all the time. Well, being honest, I think the Mets fans will actually support you because they're mad at Craig. And I think Jet fans will support Craig because he's holding their water and they don't like you. I think everyone else is up for, you know, that's the swing states, if you will. The swing states, okay. Yeah. We need a good Pennsylvania vote here. That's right. Before we check any results, who do you think is going to win that poll? Who do you trust more, Craig Cartner, Sean Moore? Sean. You think Sean will win? I mean, Craig is a Hall of Famer, so He is. He's got me, he's been around

1:31.3

for a while. Who do you trust more, Craig Carton or Sean Moore? Sean. Do you think Sean will win?

1:30.2

I mean, Craig is a Hall of Famer, so maybe Craig. He's got me, he's been around for a while. But he's never been really the news guy. He's had some, let me defend him. He's had stuff. Yeah. Absolutely. Now, I've called him out. But it's not what you think of when you think of Craig. That's true.

1:42.4

Al Dukes had a great point this morning.

1:44.1

And as you said yesterday about Al's smartest guy at WFN, he said, and I can't even imitate his voice well, he said, look, not that I don't trust Sean Morash, Evan Roberts, Craig Carton, Chris McMonigle, Greg Giannati. But when they say stuff, it's like, okay, the only people I trust with news is Boomer and Tiki.

2:03.8

It's true.

2:04.5

And I shrug my shoulders. I was like, he's kind of right. Yeah. Like even if I had some information and it was so real, it's like, oh, what the hell was heaven? No, he's not a newsbreaker. but because you are Tiki Barber and he is Boomer Ossiason, to Al's point, only two guys you could trust.

2:19.1

Meanwhile, no offense, but I mean... but because you are Tiki Barber and he is Boomer Ossyson, to Al's point, only two guys you could trust.

2:19.1

Meanwhile, no offense, but I mean, boomer said they were going to be the admirable.

2:24.3

Not the admirables, the admirals.

2:27.6

Whatever.

2:28.3

Evan, can you make me a promise to just one more final note on this?

2:31.0

I know you mark everything down.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Audacy, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Audacy and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.