meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Crimes of the Centuries

S6: ENCORE: The Manhattan Well Murder

Crimes of the Centuries

Amber Hunt and Audioboom

Society & Culture, History, Documentary, True Crime

4.74K Ratings

🗓️ 2 July 2026

⏱️ 46 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

When a 22-year-old woman living with relatives in a boarding house disappeared on Dec. 22, 1799, her loved ones didn't immediately worry. But when she still hadn't returned days later, all eyes turned to her lover, whom she'd supposedly been set to marry the last time she was seen alive. Levi Weeks came from a family with money, so his rich brother did something that was unheard of at this point in American history: He hired fancy lawyers. And that's how Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr ended up on the same side defending a man against murder charges in 1800. The case, referenced in Lin Manuel Miranda's award-winning musical "Hamilton," marks two firsts: The defense panel was America's first legal Dream Team, and the Weeks' case was the first recorded murder trial in the country's history.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hi, Crimes of the Century's listeners, Amber here. I'm still out, but I couldn't resist sharing

0:04.8

this one again. It's an encore of an episode I keep coming back to, and I wanted you to have it

0:09.7

while I'm away. I'll be back soon. Until then, enjoy.

0:19.2

Some crimes are so heartbreaking or shocking that they earn the label Crime of the Century.

0:28.1

But the stories that made headlines and decades past aren't necessarily remembered today.

0:36.0

I'm Amber Hunt, a journalist and author, and in each episode of this show, I'm Amber Hunt, a journalist and author, and in each episode of this show, I'll examine a case that's maybe lesser known today, but was huge when it happened. This is Crimes of the centuries.

1:10.4

There's never a good time for murder, of course, but there certainly are times that seem worse than others.

1:12.0

During youth, for example, or at Christmas time, or on the eve of one's wedding.

1:18.0

In the case of Giuliazza, all three of those boxes were ticked,

1:22.6

and that's among the many reasons her death still resonates after 220 years.

1:28.3

To fully grasp just how old this case is, here's a tidbit.

1:33.5

Alexander Hamilton was one of the lawyers representing the man accused in her murder.

1:38.9

And to fully grasp its historic nature, here's another.

1:43.0

Hamilton's co-counsel included Aaron Burr, the man who would

1:47.2

just a few years later shoot him dead in a duel. Not only that, but this is also the first recorded

1:54.1

homicide trial in American history. on the On the eve of 1800s

2:09.6

A city dressed in black

2:13.6

The morning of their fathers

2:16.6

The Great General to pass.

2:20.7

Catherine and Eli's ring, ran aboarden house on Greenwich Street, and the care of their

2:29.0

cousin Elmas sang.

2:33.0

Before I start, a note about the name. Some newspapers in 1800, when this story dominated the headlines

...

Transcript will be available on the free plan in 3 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Amber Hunt and Audioboom, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Amber Hunt and Audioboom and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.