On the night of November 3, 2018, a group of women gathered at a quiet home in Forsyth County, Georgia for what was supposed to be a casual

birthday sleepover. There was football on TV, drinks flowing, and nothing about the evening seemed

out of the ordinary. But by the next morning, one of these women, 40-year-old Tomla

Horsford, was dead. At first, the explanation seemed simple.

Authority said Tomla had fallen from the backyard deck in the early hours of the morning.

A tragic accident open and shut.

Case closed before it ever really began.

But almost immediately, questions started to surface.

Because when you look closer at that night, the details don't settle.

The timeline becomes unclear.

The statements don't quite match.

People who were all in the same house at the same party start telling different versions of what happened.

Small inconsistencies turn into bigger ones. What should have been a straightforward investigation begins to unravel into something far more complicated.

A case that for many never felt fully explained, and as public pressure mounted, authorities did something they don't often do. They reopened it.

Because sometimes the difference

between an accident and something else entirely comes down to the details people don't agree on.

And in this case, there are a lot of details people can't seem to agree on. So tonight, we're going

back to the beginning. Back to that house. back to that party, back to the last night

Toml Horstford was seen alive, because if you think you already know what happened, you might

want to think again.

Hey everyone, Welcome back to Crime Weekly. I'm Stephanie Harlow.

And I'm Derek Lavasar.

...