meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Darkness Radio

S21 Ep59: Curse of the Blumenthals w/Phyllis Karas

Darkness Radio

Darkness Radio

Religion & Spirituality, Spirituality, Leisure, True Crime, Hobbies

4.7 • 3.2K Ratings

🗓️ 19 May 2026

⏱️ 136 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

True Crime Tuesday Presents: Curse of the Blumenthals with Professor of Journalism/Researcher/Author, Phyllis Karas!

The Blumenthals are one of millions of Eastern European Jewish families who immigrated to the United States at the end of the nineteenth century. Settling in Providence, Rhode Island, they grow and prosper. During Prohibition, the Blumenthals became bootleggers—starting their fraught history with alcohol and crime. Once Prohibition is repealed, Barney Blumenthal opens a liquor store in Boston. Life is good—until fate intervenes.

In May 1935, a drunk driver took the lives of six Blumenthals, including three children. Horrific photos run in newspapers across the country. Six months later, Ronnie Blumenthal is born: a phoenix rising from the ashes of devastation, a golden child upon whose blond head the family’s hopes and dreams are placed. He grows into a handsome and spoiled teenager, driving a fast convertible and surrounded by beautiful girls. The Blumenthal legacy is resurrected—until one July night in 1954, when he is arrested for murder.

The victim is his mother’s seamstress, who was allegedly having an affair with his father. Newspaper and TV coverage is relentless. Ronnie pleads guilty, yet dark questions remain unanswered. Upon Ronnie’s release from prison, his drunken behavior causes the family—who faithfully visited him behind bars—to finally wash their hands of him. At the end of his life, not one family member will contribute to his funeral. The once golden child is buried in a pauper’s grave, etching the Blumenthal curse in stone.

A decade later, New York Times bestselling author Phyllis Karas, a Blumenthal cousin, uses her well-honed instincts as a journalist to peel back layers of long-hidden family secrets. Karas sensitively chronicles the generational trauma affecting Phillip and Rose Blumenthal’s six children and their children—the fifteen Blumenthal cousins—who were left to build their lives in the fallout. The Blumenthals’ story proves that, by learning from the past with care and love, curses can be broken.

On today's TCT, we talk to Phyllis about everything from the drunk driving accident that took the lives of six of her family in 1935 to the incredibly light sentence the driver of the other car received. We also talk about the legacy of Ronnie, where everything went wrong, how he managed to maintain not one, but two romantic relationships from jail, and yet couldn't maintain a relationship with his only son, and a very important question.... Is there a conspiracy behind the murder of Ora, and did Phyllis solve it? 

 Get your copy of "Curse of the Blumenthals" here:  https://bit.ly/4dhdseS

PLUS: AN ALL-NEW DUMB CRIMES/STUPID CRIMINALS WITH JESSICA FREEBURG!!

Check out Jessica Freeburg's website and get tickets to her events here:  https://jessicafreeburg.com/upcoming-events/

and check out Jess on TikTok:  https://www.tiktok.com/@jessicafreeburgwrites

For the first time, get ALL NEW TRUE CRIME TUESDAY GEAR!  Represent your favorite true crime podcast in style! There are new and different (and really cool) items all the time in the Darkness Radio Online store at our website! Check out the Darkness Radio Store!   https://www.darknessradioshow.com/store/

Make sure you update your Darkness Radio Apple Apps!
and subscribe to the Darkness Radio YouTube page:  https://www.youtube.com/@DRTimDennis

#crime #truecrime #truecrimepodcasts #truecrimetuesday #phylliskaras #curseoftheblumenthals #afamilytragedy #familycurse #drunkdriving #rhodeisland #blumenthal #barneyblumenthal #ronnieblumenthal #brookline #oraschnonarth #deathpenaltycases #criminalpsychology #narcissism #murder #strangulation #dumbcrimesstupidcriminals #TimDennis #jessicafreeburg #paranormalauthor #ghostsatoriesink #floridaman #drugcrimes #foodcrimes #stupidcrimes #funnycrimes  #sexcrimes #dumbcrimes

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Welcome into the Best in True Crime Podcasting.

0:25.4

This is True Crime Tuesday.

0:26.4

I'm your host, Tim Dennis.

0:27.6

Got a great show today, folks.

0:28.9

I'll explain to you just really quickly over the weekend.

0:32.3

The pollen exploded and so did my sinuses.

0:34.5

So you may hear it in today's episode and possibly tomorrow's as well.

0:38.8

I apologize beforehand. And I'll apologize to my guest as well. My guest today is a good one.

0:44.5

Phyllis Karris is with us and she has a book, a wonderful book that I encourage you to pick up.

0:49.4

We have it in the link. A link in the description of this program is called Curse of the Blumenthal's.

0:55.1

And a fascinating read.

0:56.7

You know, a lot of us like to trace our family history, and a lot of us have a pretty mundane family history.

1:01.9

Phyllis's family history is far from mundane.

1:05.4

Let me bring in our guest here.

1:07.0

Phyllis Karras is a professor of journalism at Boston University, a stringer for People

1:12.1

Magazine, and the author of 10 books. Brutal was a New York Times bestseller. The Onassis

1:17.5

woman was the subject of a Dateline NBC special. Her work was, or has appeared in Vogue, Miami

1:23.1

Herald, Boston Magazine, and Moment Magazine, where her story on kosher slaughter was received or had received the Simon Rockauer Award for excellence.

1:34.1

She's been interviewed on Extra Hollywood Access and Hardball.

1:38.0

And we have a link to Phyllis's website as well in the description of this program.

1:41.9

So you can check out more about Phyllis yourself.

1:43.6

Ladies and gentlemen, let's welcome into the program for the first time. Phyllis Karras. Hi, Phyllis. How are you? Hi, Tim. It's a delight to be here. Thank you. Thank you. I do want to commend you on this book. This book is highly fascinating. I mean, you know, we delve into our own family histories, And normally there's maybe a little bit of a scandal or two.

...

Transcript will be available on the free plan in 9 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Darkness Radio, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Darkness Radio and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.