Creative Battle.

This podcast contains disturbing and violent content.

Listener discretion is advised.

Previously on criminal conduct.

When paramedics arrived at the scene, Michelle Cono was barely hanging on to life.

When Mark said, I got a pulse.

Jeremy's whole demeanor changes.

And as we get out the front door,

and he swings his elbow back toward me and almost hit me in the face and he starts pacing out in the driveway and growl it.

That's all I can say. He sounds like he's growling he was angry he just was like

eight years after her death an amateur sleuth by the name of Eli

Washtalk started looking into her case he was very near close to having a conclusion to the multiple investigations that he commissioned and he'd spent tens of thousands of dollars.

The only thing he was doing with his life was investigating this murder, suicide, wherever you want to call it, that's obviously so much controversy on it and all sudden boom, you know, supposedly he's turned up some good stuff now he's gone I'm going to In 2019 Eli Washtock hired a lawyer to track down the water records for Jeremy Michelle's house

at 4,700 Sherlock Place in St. Augustine, Florida.

He wanted to figure out how much water was used around the time of her death.

I bet Eli was trying to get the water records because of what Deborah Maynard said about

Jeremy smelling like a fresh shower.

Do you think we could get the hourly water meter records?

I mean it's possible but I think it's unlikely they're going to find hourly water records

from like nine years earlier. Here let me look this up. So water meters measure water by cubic

feet, 100 cubic feet equals 750 gallons of water. An average shower uses about 17 gallons of water. I mean it sounds

crazy but it's possible that if we get an hourly report from that night it might show a spike in water use.

...