I'm Rebecca LaVoy, and this is You Can't Make This Up.

You Can't Make This Up is the podcast where we uncover the true stories behind your favorite Netflix documentaries and films.

Today, we're going back

to one true crime story you couldn't get enough of in 2025. We'll return to our discussion of

the Netflix documentary series, Amy Bradley is missing. Somebody saw her and wanted her and took her.

Today we'll revisit my conversation with directors Phil Lott and Ari Mark.

In March 1998, the Bradley family were on a Caribbean cruise when daughter Amy vanished.

She last been seen on the cabin's balcony and a ship-wide search failed to find her.

But in the following years, multiple possible sightings of Amy raised the possibility she didn't go overboard.

Instead, she could have been smuggled off the ship by island traffickers, and all this time

has been held against her will. The Netflix documentary series, Amy Bradley is missing,

explores what really happened to the cruise ship passenger three decades ago. Did she go over the rail into the ocean,

or did someone target her and spirit her away for their own purposes? The series looks at those

aboard who could have targeted her and presents the stories of those who claim to have

encountered a sex trafficked woman they believe is her. It seeks to clarify the question.

If she didn't die at sea, where is Amy Bradley today?

We were told by an FBI agent, keep your lights on.

Nobody can keep a secret their entire life.

Music And I'm joined now by directors Phil Lott and Ari Mark. Welcome to You Can't Make This Up.

Thank you. Thanks for how most. Thanks so much. Amy Bradley went missing in 1998. The story has been in and out of the news over the decades.

I'm curious, what made you want to come around and cover this one? Phil?

This is an urgent story. I mean, 1998, Amy Lynn Bradley goes on what's meant to be a dream

...