A good father is.

Somebody who's always there, you know, who shows up for the good times and the bad times.

Someone who can cry on their shoulder.

Someone who shows up for Christmas and your birthdays and who's there through your life.

That surely wasn't my father.

I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anna Sige Nikolasi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation discoveries through conviction.

And this is Anatomy of Murph.

A comment thread in every homicide story we tell is we get to celebrate the life of a victim frequently through the eyes of a loved one.

We hear about the loss of life, the love within family and the void left behind.

And as no two homicide investigations are alike, no family dynamic is the same. And today's case is a real example of that.

Today's case takes us to Point Pleasant, New Jersey and we're talking about the Burrows family.

The father was Daniel, the mom was Carol and the two kids were also named Daniel and you guessed it, Carol.

Did it take rocket science for them to name us?

We spoke with younger Carol and about a parent and what life was like growing up.

Her mom worked as a banquet manager and her dad, Daniel, well did so many different things.

It was a brick layer, truck driver, a body shop owner, a restaurant owner.

You name it, here's a jack of all trades. And he was pretty crafty.

The house Carol and grew up in was built by Daniel.

It was beautiful. It was all brick. It had a built fire, please. The kitchen and the dining room floor was made of slate.

It was just really, really cool.

You know, he really loved his toys and I'm talking about cars, motorcycles, speedboats, radio controlled airplanes.

...